West Coast Connection Forum

Lifestyle => Train of Thought => Topic started by: JTSimon on July 16, 2003, 08:08:12 AM

Title: How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: JTSimon on July 16, 2003, 08:08:12 AM
;D All religions are fake...tools to control people.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: Jimmy Cash on July 16, 2003, 08:19:30 AM
yeah, but you have to believe in something
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: mauzip on July 16, 2003, 08:36:12 AM
;D All religions are fake...tools to control people.

agreed
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: Don Seer on July 16, 2003, 08:57:52 AM
no they arent. but sadly they're misused that way.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: zevin64 on July 16, 2003, 09:08:31 AM
;D All religions are fake...tools to control people.

How do u know this? Have you analysed ALL religions? Perhaps by religion u mean some kind of belief system that people blindly follow. In such a case your own belief i.e that all religions are fake, you are blindly following.. since I don't see any evidence of you disproving all religion.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: JTSimon on July 16, 2003, 09:29:54 AM
;D All religions are fake...tools to control people.

How do u know this? Have you analysed ALL religions? Perhaps by religion u mean some kind of belief system that people blindly follow. In such a case your own belief i.e that all religions are fake, you are blindly following.. since I don't see any evidence of you disproving all religion.

Why should I have to disprove something has never proved itself.

I believe more in science and evolution process than some fairy tale Adam and Eve bible story.

And I don't understand how people still follow religions that were forced upon them centuries ago....most of Africa, Mexcio/South America for example.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: zevin64 on July 16, 2003, 10:25:42 AM
Quote

Why should I have to disprove something has never proved itself.

What you're basically trying to say is that the burden of proof falls on the believer. However, one must ask the believer of what? If you still want to add validity to your statement what you're really trying to say is that the burden of proof falls on the affirmative propsition. However, the statement 'the burden of proof falls on the affirmative proposition' is in itself an affirmative proposition and thus would require proof in itself. The statement is self-refuting and a self-refuting statement or view is false.

Quote

I believe more in science and evolution process than some fairy tale Adam and Eve bible story.

Evolution process has never been proven. The chance of a living cell arisen randomnly by chance has to be expressed in exponentials of exponentials. It's been likened to assembling a few billion blind people on the planet, give each of them a Rubix Cube, and the probabability that all of them would arive at the answer at the same time. True organic compounds have been produced in the lab by scientists but all this proves is that INTELLIGENCE is needed to produce things so complex....not just some random process. Also, if the first living cell did arise by chance then that means that your brain and thoughts are the result of random processes. How can u be sure they evolved the 'right' way or what 'right' would even mean in that context? How do u know the statements you are making are 'correct'? Maybe u trust it by faith? Evolution is just as much a religion as Christianity in that it is a belief system that alot of people blindly follow. Anyways how can u know that you don't know anything, which is what the whole evolution random process implies. The view is self-refuting and thus is false.

Scientific facts do not disprove the Bible. Only when they are interpreted by some people based on their presuppositions does it appear so.

Quote

And I don't understand how people still follow religions that were forced upon them centuries ago....most of Africa, Mexcio/South America for example.

I don't understand how people can still believe such a belief system like evolution that is false.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: JTSimon on July 16, 2003, 11:02:24 AM
;D weak attempts to discount my opinions
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: zevin64 on July 16, 2003, 11:06:57 AM
;D weak attempts to discount my opinions
Perhaps u could explain why giving some logic of your own to refute my logic.

Or you could just say something along the lines of: " Those are interesting points u make and they seem to prove your case. HOWEVER they might be wrong. Let me think about it for a while to see if they are flawed."
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: JTSimon on July 16, 2003, 11:49:22 AM
Your a spin doctor...anything I say will just be turned around.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: white Boy on July 16, 2003, 12:07:37 PM
i dont believe in religion, science has more proof, religion has no proof, and the history of religion, makes me not want to belive,
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: zevin64 on July 16, 2003, 12:36:52 PM
Your a spin doctor...anything I say will just be turned around.

Yes, so as to expose the contradictory and self-refuting nature of your statements and thus the overall general flaws in your thinking. It saves most of the work when refuting a bad argument.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: zevin64 on July 16, 2003, 12:51:35 PM
i dont believe in religion, science has more proof, religion has no proof, and the history of religion, makes me not want to belive,

Science has more proof of what? Perhaps u mean proof of our origins or why we are here. Science has no proofs of those, just theories that are modified constantly or fall to give rise to new theories.

Science can explain how some things happen, but it can't explain exactly WHY things happen. Why does our planet seem to have conditions that encourage life? To be a consistent atheist or agnostic u would have to agree with this, because looking for WHY things happen indicates that there is a purpose for things happening which only points to some kind of higher being.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: mauzip on July 16, 2003, 12:58:37 PM
damn, who cares anyway. believe what you want to believe as long as you don't harm anyone :-X
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: zevin64 on July 16, 2003, 01:10:11 PM
damn, who cares anyway. believe what you want to believe as long as you don't harm anyone :-X

That said, there is no reason the atheist should ask a christian to give "proof" of his/her religion as the atheist who "doesn't care" wouldn't care even if such proofs were reasonable since he/she is going to still cling on to his/her own biased presupposition. The atheist therefore has no real yearn for knowledge since the bottom line is he/she doesn't care. Well the consistent atheist at least.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: JTSimon on July 16, 2003, 01:11:28 PM
lol zevin64 you remind me of Ned from the Simpsons that one time when Homer took the crayon out of his nose/brain[he got really smart] and Homer proved on paper that god doesn't exist...and Ned burned the paper trying to cover it up....while Homer was passing them out in the neighborhood like flyers ;D
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: mauzip on July 16, 2003, 01:12:15 PM
damn, who cares anyway. believe what you want to believe as long as you don't harm anyone :-X

That said, there is no reason the atheist should ask a christian to give "proof" of his/her religion as the atheist who "doesn't care" wouldn't care even if such proofs were reasonable since he/she is going to still cling on to his/her own biased presupposition. The atheist therefore has no real yearn for knowledge since the bottom line is he/she doesn't care. Well the consistent atheist at least.

i don't believe in higher powers, so i'm an athiest. this doesn't mean i don't/can't respect someone else's religion.  :-X
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: OutSider on July 16, 2003, 01:19:10 PM
;D All religions are fake...tools to control people.
 right on comrade LOL!
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: zevin64 on July 16, 2003, 01:23:21 PM
Quote

i don't believe in higher powers, so i'm an athiest. this doesn't mean i don't/can't respect someone else's religion.  :-X

fair nuff

Quote
lol zevin64 you remind me of Ned from the Simpsons that one time when Homer took the crayon out of his nose/brain[he got really smart] and Homer proved on paper that god doesn't exist...and Ned burned the paper trying to cover it up....while Homer was passing them out in the neighborhood like flyers  

Lol that is quite funny. However I think the comparison is more accurate when you are Ned, who holds firmly to his respective belief system and when somebody like me, Homer comes along and offers proof as to why your belief system is wrong you try to cover it up by making fairly irrelevant comments such as the one above.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: JTSimon on July 16, 2003, 01:54:29 PM
Quote

i don't believe in higher powers, so i'm an athiest. this doesn't mean i don't/can't respect someone else's religion.  :-X

fair nuff

Quote
lol zevin64 you remind me of Ned from the Simpsons that one time when Homer took the crayon out of his nose/brain[he got really smart] and Homer proved on paper that god doesn't exist...and Ned burned the paper trying to cover it up....while Homer was passing them out in the neighborhood like flyers  

Lol that is quite funny. However I think the comparison is more accurate when you are Ned, who holds firmly to his respective belief system and when somebody like me, Homer comes along and offers proof as to why your belief system is wrong you try to cover it up by making fairly irrelevant comments such as the one above.

lol you got no proof...Spinmaster ;D


Well I believe there is a higher power over the Universe not just watching over Earth.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: Trauma-san on July 16, 2003, 05:12:12 PM
no they arent. but sadly they're misused that way.

Yup, i agree with that.  I don't believe Religions were created for that purpose, but many of them are used that way.  
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: Trauma-san on July 16, 2003, 05:13:19 PM
;D All religions are fake...tools to control people.

How do u know this? Have you analysed ALL religions? Perhaps by religion u mean some kind of belief system that people blindly follow. In such a case your own belief i.e that all religions are fake, you are blindly following.. since I don't see any evidence of you disproving all religion.

Genius statement of the week.  Religion is such a personal experience, it's impossible to discredit another's religion, because you don't understand it as they do.  
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: .:DayGoStyLz:. on July 16, 2003, 05:48:40 PM
;D All religions are fake...tools to control people.

...props

and anyone who asks how u know this, its easy. Theres thousands of religions, they are all right, they all believe they are right, therefore every other one is wrong...therefore...there all wrong.  ;D
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: Trauma-san on July 16, 2003, 06:10:06 PM
^^ You're ignorant.  Since you haven't been a member, or studied every religion, that statements impossible to make.  
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: .:DayGoStyLz:. on July 16, 2003, 10:29:15 PM
^^ You're ignorant.  Since you haven't been a member, or studied every religion, that statements impossible to make.  

Im ignorant...but u believe in a false superstition. If i believe the sky is falling, and we are all doomed...then u tell me u dont believe it too....does that make u ignorant? No, it makes u logical. Im being logical, you let yur fear of the unknown control your brain. When its all over, we'll both just be dead...except u spent your life praying to...nothing.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: .:DayGoStyLz:. on July 16, 2003, 10:30:17 PM
oh, BTW...there is no Santa Clause and there is no Easter Bunny either. Sorry to hit u with all those at once, but i figured u might as well know the truth.  ;)
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: Quakaveli on July 17, 2003, 12:36:27 AM
religion iz misused like Seer sayd. Cant call it fake lol, its unproven and like the other dude said u gotta have faith 8)
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: .:DayGoStyLz:. on July 17, 2003, 02:53:32 AM
religion iz misused like Seer sayd. Cant call it fake lol, its unproven and like the other dude said u gotta have faith 8)

if a person uses religion as a tool, to better themselves...id never knock them. But when they start to look down on others, and become so close-minded to anything else..that they are just sheep, then i gotta laff at em lol
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: Bigg AG on July 17, 2003, 04:35:04 AM
That Zevin character reminds me extremly of Owen lol... and i dont know what to believe anymore... im out!!!
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: Z the laidback Virus on July 17, 2003, 05:32:31 AM
;D All religions are fake...tools to control people.

Exactly.Once the peasants believed they would go to hell if they revolted against their leaders (all rules come from God) those leaders could keep them in check.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: zevin64 on July 17, 2003, 06:01:21 AM

Quote
lol you got no proof...Spinmaster ;D

Unless you provide reasons as to why my logic is wrong your statement sounds more like " I refuse to believe my belief system is wrong, and thus will ignore any kind of theorem with the conclusion 'evolution is false' no matter how reasonable it sounds" You have no business telling any kind of religious person you can't understand why they "blindly" follow their faith since you blindly following a belief system of your own. Or maybe you would like to try and prove it wrong...but me being the "Spinmaster" makes you afraid since I'll expose the flaws in your thinking.

Quote
Well I believe there is a higher power over the Universe not just watching over Earth.

But I suppose you'll say that this higher being created everything via the big bang and since then hasn't intervened directly. So u do follow a religion...it's called 'deism'. Welcome to the religion club.

Quote
...props

and anyone who asks how u know this, its easy. Theres thousands of religions, they are all right, they all believe they are right, therefore every other one is wrong...therefore...there all wrong.

You seem to be using the notion of religious pluralism, that all religiongs are equally true which is self-refuting.

If all religions are true then chrisitianity is true. But part of the truth of Christianity is that other religions are false. Either Christianity is correct and others are false, or some other view is true and Christianity is false. Either way all religions can't be true. And thus it also follows that they can't all be false.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: Quakaveli on July 17, 2003, 10:32:29 AM
religion iz misused like Seer sayd. Cant call it fake lol, its unproven and like the other dude said u gotta have faith 8)

if a person uses religion as a tool, to better themselves...id never knock them. But when they start to look down on others, and become so close-minded to anything else..that they are just sheep, then i gotta laff at em lol

i agree.

oh yeah, WELCOME BACK OWEN 8)
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: .:DayGoStyLz:. on July 17, 2003, 06:24:12 PM

You seem to be using the notion of religious pluralism, that all religiongs are equally true which is self-refuting.

If all religions are true then chrisitianity is true. But part of the truth of Christianity is that other religions are false. Either Christianity is correct and others are false, or some other view is true and Christianity is false. Either way all religions can't be true. And thus it also follows that they can't all be false.

Im not trying to convince anyone NOT to believe in their particular religion. It isnt part of my belief to "spread the word" lol. So i dont need PROOF that something DOESNT exist. If there is no proof that it DOES, then in the eyes of a logical person...it doesnt.
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: Trauma-san on July 17, 2003, 08:57:34 PM
^^ Yes you are.  Everytime somebody posts something about religion, you clown them.  You arrogantly think you're more intelligent than billions of religiously orientated people around the world, since you make blanket statements that they're all false, and we're all gulliable idiots who believe in superstition.  Think about how arrogant that is for a second.  

What it comes down to is, at best, you don't know whether religions are true, it doesn't interest you.  I can leave it at that; but when you say they're all false, and act like you're smart enough to realize that, and I'm not? Are you crazy?  I'm no simpleton with drool hanging out of my mouth, blindly following what somebody tells me.  I studied religion for years, thought about it for years, then decided that without a doubt, God exists.  It's not because I just accepted it, or was tricked, I'm intelligent.  I don't believe in Superstition.  For you to think that shows how ignorant, and arrogant you are.  
Title: Re:How Could I Believe in Religion?
Post by: .:DayGoStyLz:. on July 18, 2003, 02:27:28 AM
^^ Yes you are.  Everytime somebody posts something about religion, you clown them.  You arrogantly think you're more intelligent than billions of religiously orientated people around the world, since you make blanket statements that they're all false, and we're all gulliable idiots who believe in superstition.  Think about how arrogant that is for a second.  

What it comes down to is, at best, you don't know whether religions are true, it doesn't interest you.  I can leave it at that; but when you say they're all false, and act like you're smart enough to realize that, and I'm not? Are you crazy?  I'm no simpleton with drool hanging out of my mouth, blindly following what somebody tells me.  I studied religion for years, thought about it for years, then decided that without a doubt, God exists.  It's not because I just accepted it, or was tricked, I'm intelligent.  I don't believe in Superstition.  For you to think that shows how ignorant, and arrogant you are.  

Im only that harsh on religion, when dealing with certain people. Certain (from what i see) blind followers who assume their way, is the right way...and anyone not on the same "path" as them, is doomed..etc...etc. So if im harsh on you, its because i see as that. If youre not, then good...im glad to be wrong. I told u before, i never look down on a person who's using religion to better themselves. If it makes u happy, do it...i dont care. But, on a NUMBER of threads...ive told u, my beliefs COULD be wrong. I dont believe in relgion, BUT...i COULD be wrong. I dont recall u EVER doing that. So if u wanna call me "arrogant" and "ignorant", take a look in the mirror. We can leave it at, u cant prove yur right...i cant prove yur wrong. And thas it...coo?

Peace...btw, im givin u propz on this one...