Other rappers opinion on Jay's "American Gangster"

[K.Dub]

Lol at JR and Method Man

[WC Iz Active]

I couldnt believe how horrible this album was.

[Sikotic™]

Can't rappers make decent sentences and argue correctly about something 

"I liked it, I didn’t love it. Now I’m starting to really really like it now. I don’t know about loving it. -"

Just WOW

That's like asking an autistic kid to pay attention.

[ToOoOoN!!!]

lol @ this album being a classic. yeah if we put it up next to D4L or britney spears blackout but it ain't seeing any rap classics anytime soon.

lol 

[Javier]

If American Gangster is a Concept Album then...




...should also be considered one.

And also here's a real classic that has an actual theme to the entire album

[No Compute]

A thread on hip-hop concept albums would be good, one of the best:



I haven't heard American Gangster but generally most rappers have a horrible taste in music.

[Joseph Bonanno]

American Gangstaer was not a concept album. wow, he talks about selling coke and heroin, thats fresh uncharted material for rap, he captured frank lucas nuances so well

[Joseph Bonanno]

If American Gangster is a Concept Album then...




...should also be considered one.

And also here's a real classic that has an actual theme to the entire album

neither of those are concept albums either. both just had central themes. if the minstrel show was really about a minstrel show, it would sound like d4l or souljah boy

[Javier]

That's what I'm saying.  If people consider American Gangster one, then those should be mentioned as well. 

[Sikotic™]

Real fuckin concept album right here. Everybody else TALKS about making a concept album while Sticky Fingaz went ahead and did it.

[Crockett]

Real fuckin concept album right here. Everybody else TALKS about making a concept album while Sticky Fingaz went ahead and did it.

sticky kills it on this track
http://www.zshare.net/download/6290305858d219/