10 Year Anniversary - Marshall Mathers LP thread

[doggfather]

by my definition classic doesn't mean perfect. Everyone has different opinions those are mine.

I don't think there are any perfect album.

I don't think anybody could make a PERFECT album...

[Jimmy H.]

its the production that makes him...haha

You give them same Dre beats to the majority of West Coast rappers and you get three 16-bar verses about smoking weed and lowriders, you give them to Eminem and he comes up with fucking "Kill You". Haven't heard too many people that Dre works with doing anything like that. If anything, I think he's one of the least reliant on production out there. Truth is most WC rap fans would rather hear some generic rapper from the Coast spit the same style then actually listen to someone who has their own style.

[TraceOneInfinite Flat Earther 96']

 You give them same Dre beats to the majority of West Coast rappers and you get three 16-bar verses about smoking weed and lowriders, you give them to Eminem and he comes up with fucking "Kill You". Haven't heard too many people that Dre works with doing anything like that. If anything, I think he's one of the least reliant on production out there. Truth is most WC rap fans would rather hear some generic rapper from the Coast spit the same style then actually listen to someone who has their own style.

nice post

[Jaydc]

The production makes eminem?Not a chance....he can outspit 95 percent of rappers in battles and can turn around make stan which could possibly be the greatest story telling track ever in hip hop.And then turn around and make cleaning out my closet.Not many rappers have the diversity he has.

[Dre-Day]

far from perfect, because?

I can't listen to "Kim", it's actually quite irritating and horrendous to my ears. Both D-12 featured songs are mediocre and I actually always skip them not because they are wack but just forgettable. Those few flaws don't mean it can't be a classic album because the rest of the songs are pretty much all classic or at least great songs, by my definition classic doesn't mean perfect. Everyone has different opinions those are mine.

that's cool, hence i asked you to explain

i don't have KIM on my playlist either, even though i love the concept.

it is but its his damn style..why in the _ _ _ _ do you people love and adore em so much?
its the production that makes him...haha

Wrong album, fam.

lol, i think you're shooting yourself in the foot with this one.
i think it's best to leave it alone

its the production that makes him...haha

You give them same Dre beats to the majority of West Coast rappers and you get three 16-bar verses about smoking weed and lowriders, you give them to Eminem and he comes up with fucking "Kill You". Haven't heard too many people that Dre works with doing anything like that. If anything, I think he's one of the least reliant on production out there. Truth is most WC rap fans would rather hear some generic rapper from the Coast spit the same style then actually listen to someone who has their own style.

great post.
i'm not saying that other rappers couldn't have done a good job over that beat, but Eminem really did his thing on Kill You.

[you gon always be my latin queen bitch]

em has his own style, but is he as great as some make him out to be, IMO no but talkin about killin your mom, cryin about mariah, cryin about nick etc....nah im cool he dont deserve those beats
but yeah stan was/is a good song and one of his best

its the production that makes him...haha

You give them same Dre beats to the majority of West Coast rappers and you get three 16-bar verses about smoking weed and lowriders, you give them to Eminem and he comes up with fucking "Kill You". Haven't heard too many people that Dre works with doing anything like that. If anything, I think he's one of the least reliant on production out there. Truth is most WC rap fans would rather hear some generic rapper from the Coast spit the same style then actually listen to someone who has their own style.

[dubsmith_nz]

far from perfect, because?

I can't listen to "Kim", it's actually quite irritating and horrendous to my ears. Both D-12 featured songs are mediocre and I actually always skip them not because they are wack but just forgettable. Those few flaws don't mean it can't be a classic album because the rest of the songs are pretty much all classic or at least great songs, by my definition classic doesn't mean perfect. Everyone has different opinions those are mine.

There's only one song with D12 on it? Unless your thinking of Remember Me with Bizaree and Sticky Fingaz? But you can't be cos that song is fucking incredible

no the song with bizarre is what im talkin bout amityville... remember me is fukkin classic... bizarre aint on it.. rbx and sticky are

my bad bro fucked that one right up! Yeah Amityville is one of the weaker songs on the album, still dope to me but can see how you don't feel it
Lol

[BigNeckBone]

Damn time flies....
This album is a true classic and is definitely in my personal top 5
Time to give this album a spin right now

[Dre-Day]

far from perfect, because?

I can't listen to "Kim", it's actually quite irritating and horrendous to my ears. Both D-12 featured songs are mediocre and I actually always skip them not because they are wack but just forgettable. Those few flaws don't mean it can't be a classic album because the rest of the songs are pretty much all classic or at least great songs, by my definition classic doesn't mean perfect. Everyone has different opinions those are mine.

There's only one song with D12 on it? Unless your thinking of Remember Me with Bizaree and Sticky Fingaz? But you can't be cos that song is fucking incredible

no the song with bizarre is what im talkin bout amityville... remember me is fukkin classic... bizarre aint on it.. rbx and sticky are

my bad bro fucked that one right up! Yeah Amityville is one of the weaker songs on the album, still dope to me but can see how you don't feel it
Lol

you really think so?
i love Amityville, Eminem really went off on that one.

[doggfather]

B please 2 is the weaker in my opinion, nuthin xtra.
The B please is much better.

Don't know why they make a part 2?!?!

 

[Dre-Day]

i prefer it over the first version

[doggfather]

Do you?

[Dre-Day]

yep, better beat, better hook & a nice collaboration overall

[doggfather]

OK, I don't think the same, but it is ok!

The opposite: my favourite tracks is the way i am (+rock remix with marilyn manson), and remember me (everybody know the story of that track?!)

[Jaydc]

Sticky fingaz verse might have been the best verse on the album lol