Kanye West - My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy (Discussion Thread)

[Lunatic]

Dark Fantasy - 5/5
Gorgeous - 4/5
Power - 5/5
All of the Lights - 4.5/5
Monster - 4.5/5
So Appalled - 5/5
Devil in a new Dress - 5/5
Runaway - 5/5
Hell of a Life - 4.5/5
Blame Game - 5/5
Lost in the World - 3.5/5


fucking fantastic

[da chronic]

Never been a Kanye fan, but yeah... that was awesome ! 

[MoodMuzik]

I took this album serious until cham decided to call it a "musical masterpiece"


thanks cham -_-

[Chamillitary Click]

Somebody else called it a musical orgy & somebody else gave the album a "4.999999999/5"...but nobody commented on those.

I'm glad three people (although the same three people) called me out. Shows that my opinions are read time & time again.

The funniest part of this is how I've been called out twice; once for "over-praising" this album & once for "under-praising" this album & calling MM4 better. You guys are either delirious, retarded or just bitter, sitting at your keyboard going against what I say for the fuck of it. Take your pick.

[So Much Style]

wow, ok i was expecting the 2nd coming of Christ with the way you guys reviewed this shit! This is not touching his first 3 albums yall!

How the fuck can you guys bump that "toast to the douchebags, toast to the assholes" god awful song that is like 9:00 long? Also, many of the songs are too long.
Also, "pussy and religion is all I need"
Some of the shit on here IS awesome though:
the intro beat is sick as fuck, i wish the whole album woulda been like that.
Power, monster, so appalled, and devin a new dress are all dope too. Monster is the best track to me as everyone came tight.
Im not feeling blame game or the last two tracks and I am greatly dissapointed with "All of the lights"!! You guys were comparing it to "Flashing lights" WTF? Flashing lights shits all over every song on this album as do alot of Kanye's earlier tracks. This shit is 3.5/5

Since I know yall are gonna wanna know, some Songs better than every song on this album:
Flashing Lights
Touch the sky
Champion
Family Business
Gone
Spaceship
I wonder
All Falls Down

[Lunatic]

This is easily his best produced body of work

[Triple OG Rapsodie]

wow, ok i was expecting the 2nd coming of Christ with the way you guys reviewed this shit! This is not touching his first 3 albums yall!

How the fuck can you guys bump that "toast to the douchebags, toast to the assholes" god awful song that is like 9:00 long? Also, many of the songs are too long.
Also, "pussy and religion is all I need"
Some of the shit on here IS awesome though:
the intro beat is sick as fuck, i wish the whole album woulda been like that.
Power, monster, so appalled, and devin a new dress are all dope too. Monster is the best track to me as everyone came tight.
Im not feeling blame game or the last two tracks and I am greatly dissapointed with "All of the lights"!! You guys were comparing it to "Flashing lights" WTF? Flashing lights shits all over every song on this album as do alot of Kanye's earlier tracks. This shit is 3.5/5

Since I know yall are gonna wanna know, some Songs better than every song on this album:
Flashing Lights
Touch the sky
Champion
Family Business
Gone
Spaceship
I wonder
All Falls Down

Blame Game >>> Flashing Lights

You seem to vastly overrate Graduation

[IbblesAndBits]

wow, ok i was expecting the 2nd coming of Christ with the way you guys reviewed this shit! This is not touching his first 3 albums yall!

How the fuck can you guys bump that "toast to the douchebags, toast to the assholes" god awful song that is like 9:00 long? Also, many of the songs are too long.
Also, "pussy and religion is all I need"
Some of the shit on here IS awesome though:
the intro beat is sick as fuck, i wish the whole album woulda been like that.
Power, monster, so appalled, and devin a new dress are all dope too. Monster is the best track to me as everyone came tight.
Im not feeling blame game or the last two tracks and I am greatly dissapointed with "All of the lights"!! You guys were comparing it to "Flashing lights" WTF? Flashing lights shits all over every song on this album as do alot of Kanye's earlier tracks. This shit is 3.5/5

Since I know yall are gonna wanna know, some Songs better than every song on this album:
Flashing Lights
Touch the sky
Champion
Family Business
Gone
Spaceship
I wonder
All Falls Down

I agree that it's not really all that great. Nothing really stood out to me. I think "Graduation" was much, much better than MBDTF.


I will listen to it again though. Maybe It'll grow on me.

[.:Hercy Buggz:.]

this doesnt top is first album but its a great album, very well done!! I enjoy the sound of it

[Eddz]

I'm holding out until the album drops, but the temptation to download is become stronger 

[MoodMuzik]

Somebody else called it a musical orgy & somebody else gave the album a "4.999999999/5"...but nobody commented on those.

I'm glad three people (although the same three people) called me out. Shows that my opinions are read time & time again.

The funniest part of this is how I've been called out twice; once for "over-praising" this album & once for "under-praising" this album & calling MM4 better. You guys are either delirious, retarded or just bitter, sitting at your keyboard going against what I say for the fuck of it. Take your pick.

LOL damn it must feel good to think everyone is on your nuts on an internet message board

[CHUCK KNOXXX]

This is easily his best produced body of work

[Furor Teutonicus]

Somebody else called it a musical orgy & somebody else gave the album a "4.999999999/5"...but nobody commented on those.

I'm glad three people (although the same three people) called me out. Shows that my opinions are read time & time again.

The funniest part of this is how I've been called out twice; once for "over-praising" this album & once for "under-praising" this album & calling MM4 better. You guys are either delirious, retarded or just bitter, sitting at your keyboard going against what I say for the fuck of it. Take your pick.

You take yourself way too important. As always. I read through all the comments, there was enough ridiculous praise, you just had the advantage that yours came first when I searched for a quote.
But this is a nice theory you created there. Some would call it paranoia.

[Chamillitary Click]

^Seems to happen thread in & thread out; doesn't quite add up.

This is easily his best produced body of work

No way. This is the worst of his four Hip Hop albums; but those are all personal classics to me, so calling this "great/amazing" works. It honestly lacks those standout songs that we'll remember for years & years; that "classic" song, that sticks, that all his other albums had.

Production wise, it's right there, but overall, it's last; which is still great, considering what it's going up against.

[Triple OG Rapsodie]

This album is considerably better than Graduation