What do you think of D12 over a dozen years later?

[TraceOneInfinite Flat Earther 96']

I mean it had great production. And Em was on point but it seems the only reason it sold and got so much attention was because of em, it's nice to look back to see how dope Mr Porter was back then, as a producer and hook vocalist ashame this album will probably get remembered more than Dogg Food where the homies of an great mc atop of the world didn't  rode his coat tails and did their own thing

Yeah, it sold because of Eminem, but you could also argue that Dogg Food sold because of Snoop.  Snoop had his little cameo in "Let's Play House", he also was on the chorus and kicking down buildings in "New York, New York", and he was all over the album in general contributing a lot to its style and flavor.  Snoop was also in his prime at that time much like Em so I think a lot of his success rubbed off on the Dogg Pound.  Also... keep in mind Daz put out a solid LP in 98 that had much of the same Dogg Pound/Death Row sound and it didn't even go gold.  So Snoop's image and appeal at the time of Dogg Food really boosted sales amongst casual fans.

I think the Dogg Food record was a superior album and I wouldn't worry about anybody putting Devils Night ahead of that album.  

[Lucifuge]

Devils night is most ounderated album ever. Shit is so dark and dope. Bizarre is that dude  funny as fuck. Also Kuniva and Proof shining.

[Black Excellence]

Anyone could sound good with Dr Dre working with them

[Blood$]

Anyone could sound good with Dr Dre working with them

if Young Thug hopped on a Dre track how would that sound?

[Chamillitary Click]

Anyone could sound good with Dr Dre working with them

if Young Thug hopped on a Dre track how would that sound?

Well a couple months ago that cocksucker would say "awful", but since he did the track with Clifford, I wouldn't be surprised if Young Thug is in his top five.

[sofdark]

As an individual rappers, D-12 members didn't really stand out but as a group, I think they held their ground. They came correct on their albums and the features they did on Eminem albums.

No doubt sales were boosted with Eminem buzz and the production qualities being top notch with the golden era Aftermath producers.

[WestSideDon]

The group was ok to me, i never was that much into eminem or d12. I actually got devils night & d12 world on my itunes, listened to them a while ago and especially on the first one there were some dope songs. The most annoying thing about them was always Bizarre, this guy was just in the groupe for shock value and absolutely, I mean ABSOLUTELY NOTHING ELSE. I mean he has zero rapskills, I don't know a song where he actually sounds good or shows some kind of flow. If they were out for shock value they couldve also let eminem deliver those lyrics, he was dope back then so there was no need for bizarre.

[Black Excellence]

Anyone could sound good with Dr Dre working with them

if Young Thug hopped on a Dre track how would that sound?

I don't know and I really don't care.

[Black Excellence]

Anyone could sound good with Dr Dre working with them

if Young Thug hopped on a Dre track how would that sound?

Well a couple months ago that cocksucker would say "awful", but since he did the track with Clifford, I wouldn't be surprised if Young Thug is in his top five.

young thug won't ever be nowhere near a list of mine. go eat a dick prag !

[Hack Wilson - real]

Anyone could sound good with Dr Dre working with them

if Young Thug hopped on a Dre track how would that sound?

Well a couple months ago that cocksucker would say "awful", but since he did the track with Clifford, I wouldn't be surprised if Young Thug is in his top five.

lol

[Blood$]

Anyone could sound good with Dr Dre working with them

if Young Thug hopped on a Dre track how would that sound?

I don't know and I really don't care.

so then not just anyone would sound good with Dre 

[Black Excellence]

[me1]

That first album is raw as hell. And Dre had next to nothing to do with it. He produced what, 4 joints of the 18 or so? I don't remember. Maybe not even that many. That was 100% Em and his crew's chemistry that made it dope. And yeah, I couldn't tell the 3 of those dudes apart for years (Kuniva, Kon Artis, Swifty McVeigh), but it didn't matter. One of my favorite group albums of all time.