Lifestyle > Sports & Entertainment

Good read on Peyton Manning in the playoffs.

<< < (3/3)

OG Hack Wilson:
do you guys not realize that Dan Marino wouid KILL for a ring?


who the hell criticizes someone with a ring lmao


marino is called by many ppl "the greatest ever"   (while i disagree) despite having NO ring

Jaydc:
Rings are nice but they dont determine a players worth.In every sport their is amazing players hat nevr get to win the big championship.

Barry sanders in the greatest running back of all time and didnt win a ring.

OG Hack Wilson:

--- Quote from: Jaydc's better is better then your better on December 07, 2009, 10:30:05 PM ---Rings are nice but they dont determine a players worth.In every sport their is amazing players hat nevr get to win the big championship.

Barry sanders in the greatest running back of all time and didnt win a ring.

--- End quote ---

donovan mcnabb is one of the best QB's ive seen in my life and he's never won a ring

Chamillitary Click:
stop putting words in my mouth.

nobody is questioning Peyton being great; it's you people calling Tom a scrub.

Shallow:

--- Quote from: Chamillitary Click on December 08, 2009, 12:09:39 PM ---stop putting words in my mouth.

nobody is questioning Peyton being great; it's you people calling Tom a scrub.

--- End quote ---


You said he can't get it done in the playoffs. I say the best QB performance I've ever seen with my own to eyes was a loss by Indy against Pit. That's where you and me differ. You think a great performance is based around score, stats, or wins. I think it's based on performance in the face of adversity. The entire game Peyton was bumped, sacked, and had no one open, and no run game but they were still one shift to the right by Nick Harper from winning. And no other QB in the game in my opinion would have been with in 2 scores of the Steelers when it was all said an done.

What I saw from Peyton on that day made me realize how much better he is than anyone playing at that time and right now. He wasn't perfect. A rushed throw to Troy that should have been INT'd and two long endzone passes to Wayne instead of checking down for more yards at the very end for the FG were all Peyton's fault, and the latter could have been the difference. But in my opinion he was better than anyone could have possibly been in the situation he was in. Because no other QB would have had the chance to make those errors in judgment at the very end, because the gae would have already been out of reach..

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page