Lifestyle > Sports & Entertainment
Wow this arizona-green bay game is amazing
Shallow:
--- Quote from: Chamillitary Click on January 10, 2010, 05:44:59 PM ---
--- Quote from: Lunatic on January 10, 2010, 05:41:33 PM ---the booth should have reviewed it as a precaution but i don't think anything should have been overturned
--- End quote ---
but they can't review it & then say, "actually there was holding on the play".
--- End quote ---
I think they could have called the 15 yard fask mask penalty. The only questin would have been whether it would have counted as roughing the passer. A face mask after the fumble just backs up the cards a bit and they score. a Face mask during the fumble means 15 yards a first down for GB, but in Arizona that might lead to trouble.
You don't have to challenge the penalty. You can challenge the fumble and then they can see whatever they see.
Jaydc:
Yeah but thats the same thing.A penalty isnt reviewable.They cant reverse a call based on a penalty they missed.If someone got a touchdown they cant review the play and be like hey there was holding on that play we can reverse it.the rules are pretty clear on that.
Shallow:
--- Quote from: Special Agent Jaydc M.D. on January 10, 2010, 06:05:32 PM ---Yeah but thats the same thing.A penalty isnt reviewable.They cant reverse a call based on a penalty they missed.If someone got a touchdown they cant review the play and be like hey there was holding on that play we can reverse it.the rules are pretty clear on that.
--- End quote ---
Yes it is. The Music City Miracle was reviewed based on that exactly. It was determined that the ball was pass backwards, but if it was forward it would not have counted as a TD.
Jaydc:
A pass backwards isnt the same as a holding or a facemask or a pass interference.....
Shallow:
--- Quote from: Special Agent Jaydc M.D. on January 10, 2010, 06:16:15 PM ---A pass backwards isnt the same as a holding or a facemask or a pass interference.....
--- End quote ---
Ok, maybe. All I know was you said penalty and I know it's happened before. All I know is I hear every time they review anything is that they say that only certain things are challenge-able but once under the booth the ref can call anything he wants.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version