It's May 23, 2024, 04:30:00 PM
Once a play has been challenged, the entire play is open to review. That means that a coach could challenge one particular aspect of a play but the official may see something else that was missed instead.Penalties and whether they should or should not have been called cannot be reviewed. Almost everything else can be reviewed, including completions, turnovers, spotting of the ball, in-bounds/out of bounds calls, scoring plays and so on.
ya, penalties are not reviewable and I believe it should stay that way.
Quote from: Lunatic on January 10, 2010, 06:26:35 PMya, penalties are not reviewable and I believe it should stay that way.i don't know.those pass interferences happen so fast & the WR always wins; i think slowed down, many calls would get overturned.
Quote from: Chamillitary Click on January 10, 2010, 06:29:26 PMQuote from: Lunatic on January 10, 2010, 06:26:35 PMya, penalties are not reviewable and I believe it should stay that way.i don't know.those pass interferences happen so fast & the WR always wins; i think slowed down, many calls would get overturned.Pass interference and holding are one thing. They are subjective. A face mask is not subjective. He either has his face mask in hand or not. Just like a forward fumble, or an illegal forward pass.
The game I find would slow down a lot if penalties were reviewable. I understand the argument to make them so, but I disagree.
Quote from: Lunatic on January 10, 2010, 06:36:42 PMThe game I find would slow down a lot if penalties were reviewable. I understand the argument to make them so, but I disagree. Agreed,people would be calling for reviews after every big play looking for some small infraction
How are they subjective?Theirs rules and you break them theirs a penalty,just like a face mask.Either you hold someone or you dont,that isnt subjective.