Lifestyle > Sports & Entertainment

Carmelo is officially a Knick

<< < (3/4) > >>

OG Hack Wilson:
is Carmelo still a top 10 NBa player?

Lunatic:

--- Quote from: Carlton Banks on February 21, 2011, 10:59:41 PM ---is Carmelo still a top 10 NBa player?

--- End quote ---
Absolutely

Top 10 IMO (no order)

LeBron
Kobe
D Wade
Durant
Carmelo
Dwight Howard
Rondo
CP3
Derrick Rose
Amare/Pau Gasol

I feel like it's really close between Amare and Gasol. Amare has been in beast mode this year but Gasol gives you every statistic.

Just missing the cut: Carlos Boozer, Russell Westbrook, Kevin Love, Derron Williams, Blake Griffin & Joe Johnson. Westbrook, Love & Griffin all will break through that list soon.

I excluded guys like Tim Duncan, Steve Nash & Dirk Nowitzki (all getting old).

7even:
I agree with this article: http://www.nba.com/2011/news/features/shaun_powell/02/22/carmelo.trade.reaction/index.html

Melo is a bitch, instead of signing as a FA for less money to a true contender he decided to let the Knicks get absolutely gutted in that trade.
Now it's only Amare (scorer, no defense), Melo (scorer, no defense) and Billups (aging, bad season, falling the fuck off) and a bunch of little bitches.
Not even close to a contender... and not any pieces to give up in a trade for another All-Star caliber player. Not any cap room to sign another max contract FA with once the new cap is in effect.

'EclipZe:
bad move by the knicks....

Chamillitary Click:
You cannot win a ring in the D'antoni system unless you have a lineup of:

CP3/Deron
Wade/Kobe
LeBron/Melo
Amare/Bosh
Dwight

lol.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page