Lifestyle > Sports & Entertainment
2012 Superbowl Thread.
Lunatic:
Pats finna' be butthurt 0-2 in the Super Bowl vs. the Giants
Shallow:
--- Quote from: Chamillitary Click; #TeamBox on January 24, 2012, 06:09:23 PM ---
--- Quote from: Shallow on January 24, 2012, 06:08:24 PM ---
--- Quote from: Chamillitary Click; #TeamBox on January 24, 2012, 05:59:37 PM ---None of that relatively comes close to changing the fact that Cruz & Nicks just make plays after catching the ball.
--- End quote ---
Who is trying to change the fact? I never said Eli is better than Brady because his WRs can't YAC.
--- End quote ---
Eli looks good at all because his WR make plays for him.
--- End quote ---
The stuff I see from Eli, specifically, makes me say he's better than Brady. Brady makes less bad decisions but Eli makes more great throws. So this parts even out. Eli's ability to find the safe out when he's getting smashed by the defense really impressed me in that Niners game, and after getting crunched the way he still called the time out, and the way he ran to Coughlin after seeing the play clock. He showed the toughness and grit of an old style QB. Rodgers has a superstar cast and a great system but things I see from him are still very special. I don't see all these special things from Brady; he's just a solid QB on a great team. And that team would still have the #1 seed and still be playing in the Superbowl this year if they had kept Cassel instead of Brady.
Peyton is still head and shoulders above the rest the best single player right now, but Eli showed me something special this season.
Lunatic:
Rodgers & Brees are the two best QB's in the NFL
OG Jaydc:
Nah this is why you can't talk Brady or manning because your bias is so blinding. If Tom Brady put up that same performance that Eli did you wouldn't be impressed, you'd bring up the same points I made and the same points Cham made. If Eli had a great game you'd have a point but he didn't and you don't.
Chamillitary Click:
A year ago today Giants fans were talking about making a switch after he lead the NFL in interceptions after a failure of a Giants season completely on him.
There has never been a moment in Brady's career where he was doubted by the Patriot faithful.
You beat great teams with great defensive line play & the Giants (by far) have the most superior D-line in the game. Tuck, Pierre-Paul, Cruz & Nicks mean more to the Giants than Eli Manning. Now this will hurt because I believe you said you hate the man, but Giants would be in the same, if not a better position if they never traded away Phillip Rivers.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version