Lifestyle > Sports & Entertainment

Which quarterback would you rather have next season?

(1/16) > >>

rayallen0:
Peyton Manning in 2010:
4,700 yds, 32 TDs, 17 INTs, 66.3% cpg, 91.9 rating
Cam Newton in 2011:
4,051 yds, 21 TDs, 17 INTs, 60.0% cpg, 84.5 rating

"THE" MoSav:
CAM and its not even close, nothing against Peyton but besides one grainy video we know nothing about how hes healing..Cam is a special talent Like peyton is that will only come along once or so in a lifetime his size speed arm strength body size everything, its unreal

Shallow:

--- Quote from: "THE" MoSav on March 09, 2012, 01:07:51 PM ---CAM and its not even close, nothing against Peyton but besides one grainy video we know nothing about how hes healing..Cam is a special talent Like peyton is that will only come along once or so in a lifetime his size speed arm strength body size everything, its unreal

--- End quote ---

Now we're starting to get back to where we were.

Let me make it very clear that I would not as Carolina's GM bring in Peyton under any circumstances, because we'd have no chance at a Superbowl on that shit team either way.


But give me a fucking break if you'd rather have Cam than Peyton on a contender for next year, and next year alone. Let's say both Baltimore and Houston were in the hunt and both Peyton and cam are available, whoever gets Peyton goes farther than whoever gets Cam. And that's a fucking guarantee. Cam put up a lot of yards in a lot of games coming from behind in an era where you can't touch WRs past 5 yards.

And even then he started way better than he finished. The first 8 games before the bye Cam had 1 game under 200 and 3 games in the vicinity of 400. The 8 games after the bye he had 5 games under 200 and no games over 300 yards. Peyton started much slower but finished much stronger in his rookie season.

I don't care where his arm strength is, his head alone makes him better than Cam right now for a one season situation.

Chamillitary Click:
^Is that the alias or the real Shallow?

As for my pick:

Shallow:

--- Quote from: Chamillitary Click; #TeamBox on March 10, 2012, 02:50:07 PM ---^Is that the alias or the real Shallow?

As for my pick:



--- End quote ---


Yeah, but you'd take Sanchez over Peyton.

For the record I wouldn't think about Sanchez over Newton. I think Newton has all the potential in the world, and a great future ahead of him, but were talking 1 season for 1 season only, and no way would any GM take Cam over Peyton in that scenario if the stipulation was Superbowl victory or you're fired for life: it's Peyton and it's an insult of a debate.

And I'll fully agree that I'd take cam over Peyton if I were re-building and looking towards being a contender for the future, but for "next season" Peyton's going to be in the MVP race (you can quote me on that) and Cam won't even be close to it.

Y

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page