Lifestyle > Sports & Entertainment

WHO IS THE GREATEST QB OF ALL TIME?

(1/15) > >>

Sccit:
was listenin to 710am today and max kellerman was arguing peyton manning... who u got as the GOAT qb? john elway? joe montana? tom brady? dan marino? whos ur greatest qb and whats ur case for them bein the goat??

Hack Wilson - real:
peyton manning


he'll end up with every major record ever and probably 2 rings, maybe 3

Chamillitary Click:
Montana.

Sccit:

--- Quote from: Chamillitary Click on January 28, 2014, 08:44:27 PM ---Montana.

--- End quote ---

whats ur case for montana?

M Dogg™:
My case for Montana is that he changed the game. Montana was the first true Westcoast Offensive QB, and since then people have tried to replicate him over and over. Though it was an offence based off short passes, it created a new strategy in which the running game was not needed because now the swing pass was the new running game. Montana then added that with the fact he was cold ass ice in clutch time. Once the clock started ticking down, that's when Montana was at his best. I was a little kid and it was just seen as inevitable that the 49ers would comeback in the 4th quarter and win. The Packers in the 90's and the Colts/Patriots in the 2000's both had that feel too. So because watching all these great QB's I saw very little space between them, then I go by who changed the game. It's unfair to judge a QB in the 60's with the QB's now, because now they pass way more. And Montana was the type of game managers that Brady, Manning and Favre were. So the tie breaker to me is Super Bowls and then who changed the game. And in that, Montana has the edge.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page