Lifestyle > Train of Thought
Was the Berg killing justified?
Montana00:
we just talked about this but i guess this should be its own topic. ill bring back some of my arguements.
First off, No, this was no justified. i mean if i saw somene punching my brother does that give me the right to kill him...no. This was SO MUCH worse then what we did to them. As stated above....they did this to be the most painful bloody thing. they SAWED his head off no CHOPPED. for anyone who saw the video you know what they did.
OK YOU WANT TO TALK ABOUT REVENGE? About a couple of months ago some american were in fallujah, iraq. They killed 4 or so americans. After that they preceded to set fire to one of the bodies. They then tore off body parts of 2 others, and threw the arms and legs around like they were sticks. They then hung the bodies on a bridge laughing and screaming. This was an outrage to us americans.
So isnt it justifiable to say that since they did that to us then we could do the iraqi prison abuse to them? i see no difference and niether should you. im not in anyway condoning the prison abuse. But if you can sit there and say the beheading was justified then you better fucking say that we were justified by there actions. read all about it on this link. its got some beautiful pictures as well. These picture below could make me care less about iraqi peoples well being.
WARNING EXTREMELY GRAPHIC. (not graphic like the iraqi prison photos...actually graphic)
http://www.thememoryhole.org/war/fallujah_31mar04/
ok short answer No not justified.
Now_Im_Not_Banned:
Did he torture Iraqi prisoners? NO, SO IT'S NOT JUSTIFIED...Holy shit, you have to be stupid to even ask this question.
Don Seer:
^ and beyond that.
most of the "civilised world" outside america doesnt think death is ever a fitting punishment.
Real American:
--- Quote from: Kain670 on May 15, 2004, 08:44:00 AM ---
What was Al Qaeda motive besides revenge for the prisoner abuse by cutting his head off ? opinions
--- End quote ---
Nick Berg was killed simply because he was American and Jewish. As for their motive, what was the motive when the Italian hostage was executed in Iraq last month, or when the 4 American civilains were murdered, dismembered, dragged, and hung, or when Muslims beheaded Daniel Pearle in Pakistan, or when Abu Sayaf Muslims beheaded the American missionary couple in the Phillipines a year ago, or when Muslims commit any of the hundreds and hundreds of violent terrorist attacks.
Their motive is that they are Islamic psychopaths who want to kill anyone who is different.
Montana00:
yea i agree ^^^
But think of it this way. This beheading is nothing new to these muslims....
Remember Daniel pearl anyone???? Heres a quick tip. THERE WAS NO IRAQ WAR WHEN HE WAS BEHEADED. The muslims beheaded him pureley because he was jewish. They kidnapped him, made him say to the camera he was jewish, and they beheaded him.
lets face it those guys muslims who beheaded Nick berg just wanted an excuse to behead another jew. If this was the first time i wouldve said otherwise, but this beheading isnt anything new. there just after jews.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version