Lifestyle > Sports & Entertainment

Star Wars Episode III (rate it here!)

<< < (5/7) > >>

Kal EL:
My point was he wouldn't have been aware that Padme didn't die until Luke showed up, 18 years later.  OK?  YOU GOT THAT?

--- Quote ---
--- End quote ---

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

It was inferred in that scene that Padme and the child did not survive. It mattered to Vader in that moment 1.that she was dead and 2.that HE was the one that killed her(or so he was led to believe).

But nevertheless I understand your perspective. Sidious is his PIMP.

Juronimo:
This movie is fuckin sick. 9/10

Machiavelli:
2nd best movie from the whole series - 9/10

Episode I - 7/10
Episode II - 7.5/10
Episode III - 9/10
Episode IV - 8.5/10
Episode V - 9.5/10
Episode VI - 8.5/10

shamihundal:
9 good movie

Trauma-san:

--- Quote from: Kal EL on May 20, 2005, 02:15:33 PM ---My point was he wouldn't have been aware that Padme didn't die until Luke showed up, 18 years later.  OK?  YOU GOT THAT?

--- Quote ---
--- End quote ---

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

It was inferred in that scene that Padme and the child did not survive. It mattered to Vader in that moment 1.that she was dead and 2.that HE was the one that killed her(or so he was led to believe).

But nevertheless I understand your perspective. Sidious is his PIMP.

--- End quote ---

I think you're misunderstanding something. Who said Vader didn't think Padme died?  I don't even get what you're arguing about.  This is clear:

Padme died in Childbirth.  They said in the movie she gave up the will to live (obviously because Anakin was presumed dead, or because she knew Anakin had went to the dark side before she went unconscious)

Sidious told Vader that he had killed Padme, and Vader said that she was alive after he choked her, he could feel it. 

Then from what we know, years later he finds out Luke Skywalker is alive, and garners luke is his son through the name.

I don't get what you're saying about what was inferred.  Of course it was inferred, how does that differ from what I've said?

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page