Lifestyle > Train of Thought

Ariel Sharon Is Finished in Politics

<< < (16/19) > >>

virtuoso:

Geezy do you think Israel has a right to keep palestinian land?

virtuoso:

Erase that, I already know you will say yes  :(

I TO DA GEEZY:
Define Palestinian Land...lol
 Do you think the Jewish People are entitled to a state?

J @ M @ L:

--- Quote from: I TO DA GEEZY on January 17, 2006, 10:35:02 AM ---Define Palestinian Land...lol
 Do you think the Jewish People are entitled to a state?

--- End quote ---

If it means killing and removing the indigenous population of a land and not allowing them to return... then No.

Let me ask you this... in the case of Europeans coming to America... were the Native Americans the victims or the Europeans?
Any person with even a minimal amount of common sense and knowledge will tell you it was obviously the Native Americans.
Now just switch America with Palestine, and Native Americans with Palestinians and you have yourself the truth.

Also, ask yourself... who was living there, and who arrived to colonize... that will tell you who has "claim" to the land.

I TO DA GEEZY:
Your analogy is flawed.
Europeans who came to colonize America already had national homes/countries.
Europeans who came to colonize America weren't persecuted because they didn't have a national home.
Europeans who came to colonize America wanted to force their culture and religion on the native population.

Jews came back to their Historical homeland, from which they were exiled, to save themselves from Anti-semitism.

Jews didn't have a national home
Jews were persecuted for centuries because they didn't have a national home
Jews didn't come with an intention to force anything on the native population

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page