West Coast Connection Forum
DUBCC - Tha Connection => West Coast Classics => Topic started by: HBKid_Jr on December 29, 2001, 07:54:57 PM
-
I know tha chronic got 4 mics but didnt they have an issue in which they said tha chronic deserved a higher rating, did they change it an also what other albums did they say deserved better rating than what they received, i heard e.1999.eternal was one
-
dogg , we are talkin about tha chronic in the other post, y didn' u ask your question back there dogg..anyways
-
The source didn't change the raitings but they said The Chronic, 36 Chambers and Reasonable Doubt should have been classics.
-
The source didn't change the raitings but they said The Chronic, 36 Chambers and Reasonable Doubt should have been classics.
they do change the marks , but it was already print fo ages so they just talkin, whut they should do his a mag where all the album would be place with their true mark over the years
-
dogg , we are talkin about tha chronic in the other post, y didn' u ask your question back there dogg..anyways
cuz i expanded tha question an asked what other albums did they mention
-
well aight , on a side yeah.. there's many of them , most of them classic people talk about , i think they gave tha real classic mark to few people. like 5 or som e, ice cube , nas, outkast, hmm , some n nowadays , jay-z , nas
-
Chronic got 4.5 mics. That album was one of several [some others include, Cuban Linx, E.1999 Eternal, and Ready to Die] of which the Source admitted they fucked up on.
-
didn't the source end up sayin that doggystyle and all eyez on me were classics too?
-
yeah yeah all the classic u know bout
-
one thing i remember is they gave da game is to be sold and retaliation revenge and get back 4 mics each ;D
-
The Source should put out an issue printing out all they're ratings from the past - for real. Thenwe could all see this shit.
Wow, how could The Source NOT recognize that "The Chronic" was a revolution lyrically and beat wise? Admit it, those were some powerfull, provacative lyrics that Snoop, Kurupt, Rage and RBX came with.
The beats too were a sonic marval.
I think both "The Chonic" and "2001" are classics...but if you could go out of the realm and give an extra small point to one of the albums...I think it would be "The Chronic."
-
Confirm These Source Ratings Now
The Chronic:
Doggystyle:
36 Chambers:
E.1999 Eternal:
Cuban Link:
2001:
ALSO...I need someone to name some albums that got some ratings that aren't deserved...like Made Men.
-
da game is 2 be sold got 4 mics. that album deserves 3 at most
-
one thing i remember is they gave da game is to be sold and retaliation revenge and get back 4 mics each ;D
lol
-
Who cares how many mics each album got in The Source and which ones are classics according to them. We, the fans, decide which albums get to be called "classics". And it can't be done over a week or two after an album's release, oh no. Look into Stillmatic or Blueprint or whatever album after, like, a year or two. THEN, if those discs are still in your CD player and you still can't get enough, THEN it's a classic. The Chronic, All Eyes on Me, Doggystyle, Chronic 2001, Illmatic and so on are classic albums 'cause people still buy them, people still listen to them and people still talk about them. A magazine can't say what's classic or not with listening to the album a few times. Only YOU can tell a classic, over time.
-
Who cares how many mics each album got in The Source and which ones are classics according to them. We, the fans, decide which albums get to be called "classics". And it can't be done over a week or two after an album's release, oh no. Look into Stillmatic or Blueprint or whatever album after, like, a year or two. THEN, if those discs are still in your CD player and you still can't get enough, THEN it's a classic. The Chronic, All Eyes on Me, Doggystyle, Chronic 2001, Illmatic and so on are classic albums 'cause people still buy them, people still listen to them and people still talk about them. A magazine can't say what's classic or not with listening to the album a few times. Only YOU can tell a classic, over time.
amen to this.
-
Confirm These Source Ratings Now
The Chronic:
Doggystyle:
36 Chambers:
E.1999 Eternal:
Cuban Link:
2001:
ALSO...I need someone to name some albums that got some ratings that aren't deserved...like Made Men.
Chronic--4.5 mics [shoulda been 5]
Doggystyle--4 mics [shoulda been 5]
36 Chambers--4.5 mics I think, [shoulda been a 5 in anycase]
E.1999 Eternal--4 mics [shoulda been 5]
Cuban Linx--4.5 mics [shoulda been 5]
2001--4.5 mics [shoulda been a 4 at the most]
-
In all honesty, I think the Source has underrated far more albums then they have overrated. They are NOT good at recognizing classic material, as seen by the fact they've only give 5 mics to like 12 albums or some shit. But in reality, there are at least another 50 albums that didnt get the 5 mics but deserved it, including all the ones I named in my last post [except 2001]. But, here are some OVERRATED albums:
Hot Boys Guerrilla Warfare--4.5 mics [shoulda got a 3 at the most]
Life After Death--5 mics [4.5 mics is more accurate]
The Blueprint--5 mics [again, 4.5 is more accurate]
I Am--4.5 mics [this is a 4 at the most]
Supreme Clientele--4.5 mics [this is about 4 mics]
Bulletproof Wallets--4.5 mics [this is closer to 3.5 mics]
Great Depression--4 mics [this is a 3.5 tops]
Hardknock Life--4.5 mics [this is TRASH, shoulda got 1 mic]
Dynasty--4.5 mics [3 mics tops]
Life And Times Of S. Carter--4 mics [2 mics tops]
-
Thanks Hellrazor.
Final Q: What did "The Slim Shady LP" & "Marshall Mathers LP" get?
-
im pretty sure e.1999.eternal was 3.5 mics an 2001 one wit out a doubt deserved 4.5 mics if not 5
-
Chronic--4.5 mics [shoulda been 5]
Doggystyle--4 mics [shoulda been 5]
36 Chambers--4.5 mics I think, [shoulda been a 5 in anycase]
E.1999 Eternal--4 mics [shoulda been 5]
Cuban Linx--4.5 mics [shoulda been 5]
2001--4.5 mics [shoulda been a 4 at the most]
they were claim classic except fo cuban link , where did u get that from ??? ,eminem got 4 if i remember cause it was in the same issue of dre n dre was higher , if i remember.... the first i don't know , and the game got his 4 mics, well all snoop's album got 4 mic except fo doggystyle
-
im pretty sure e.1999.eternal was 3.5 mics an 2001 one wit out a doubt deserved 4.5 mics if not 5
Are you sure E.1999 Eternal got only 3.5?? I coulda sworn it was 4. But if it indeed only got 3.5, that has to be one of The Source's top 3 fuck ups.......thats just inexcusable.
-
Are you sure E.1999 Eternal got only 3.5?? I coulda sworn it was 4. But if it indeed only got 3.5, that has to be one of The Source's top 3 fuck ups.......thats just inexcusable.
i read it at tha hitemup board cuz i thought it was 2.5 mics an he said no they gave 3.5 mics
-
Thats a disgrace right there.....
Im happy that Stillmatic got 5 mics, cuz lord knows, that album deserved it, but the Source cant hide their history. No matter much good doing they do from here on out, they will never be fully credible as far as im concerned, cuz they've fucked up on too many albums.....and too many great albums at that.
-
SSLP & MMLP...how many mics?
I think MMLP got 3.5...am I right?
-
the marshall mathers lp got 4 mics and i think that it shoulda got 4.5 cuz that shit ruled last year!!!
and whoever said that the game is to be sold not told got 4 mics is wrong because it got 3.5 like all of the other shitty no limit releases
-
So what did "The Slim Shady LP" get?
-
Snoops Da Game only got 3.5...Both Top Dogg and Last Meal got 4 mics...Doggystyle got 4 and Doggfather wasn't reviewed...E.1999 Eternal got 3.5...The Art Of War was the one they gave 4 mics...The Source seems to underrate mostly West Coast shit I think the only artist to get 5 mics was Cube...
-
Snoops Da Game only got 3.5...Both Top Dogg and Last Meal got 4 mics...Doggystyle got 4 and Doggfather wasn't reviewed...E.1999 Eternal got 3.5...The Art Of War was the one they gave 4 mics...The Source seems to underrate mostly West Coast shit I think the only artist to get 5 mics was Cube...
BTNHresurrection and Family Scriptures both got 4 mics also.
That just goes to show you that the Source doesnt know DIDDLY SHIT. They rated AOW and Resurrection higher than E.1999 Eternal........what a joke. I love AOW but it doesnt touch E.1999 Eternal by any means.
-
In all honesty, I think the Source has underrated far more albums then they have overrated. They are NOT good at recognizing classic material, as seen by the fact they've only give 5 mics to like 12 albums or some shit. But in reality, there are at least another 50 albums that didnt get the 5 mics but deserved it, including all the ones I named in my last post [except 2001]. But, here are some OVERRATED albums:
Hot Boys Guerrilla Warfare--4.5 mics [shoulda got a 3 at the most]
Life After Death--5 mics [4.5 mics is more accurate]
The Blueprint--5 mics [again, 4.5 is more accurate]
I Am--4.5 mics [this is a 4 at the most]
Supreme Clientele--4.5 mics [this is about 4 mics]
Bulletproof Wallets--4.5 mics [this is closer to 3.5 mics]
Great Depression--4 mics [this is a 3.5 tops]
Hardknock Life--4.5 mics [this is TRASH, shoulda got 1 mic]
Dynasty--4.5 mics [3 mics tops]
Life And Times Of S. Carter--4 mics [2 mics tops]
Life After Death deserved 5 mics. It changed the game.
surpreme clientele deserved 4.5 mics.
The bullet proof wallets that the source reviewed had the tracks taken off the retail version of bpw such as the sun, the watch, (original) version of flowers. Put those tracks on this cd and it easily deserves a 4.5 with tracks like the forrest, street chemistry and the hilton.
-
First what people need to realize is the source mind quad (the people who review the albums) constantly changes. So the people who reviewed AOW aren't the same people who reviewed E. 1999. The same people who reviewed the chronic didn't review 2001. The source has made some mistakes. However some of you peeps take ratings tooooooooooo serious. Come on, be fo' real. It's their opinion, and if you don't like it, deal with it. As long as you like the album then you shouldn't have a problem with it.
However the source does make some messed up reviews
-
Life After Death had impact, but I still think All Eyez On Me had more impact, cuz that was the album that started the double cd trend......and the Source didnt even rate All Eyez On Me......
-
Snoops Da Game only got 3.5...Both Top Dogg and Last Meal got 4 mics...Doggystyle got 4 and Doggfather wasn't reviewed...E.1999 Eternal got 3.5...The Art Of War was the one they gave 4 mics...The Source seems to underrate mostly West Coast shit I think the only artist to get 5 mics was Cube...
how come doggfather didn't get reviewed ??? anyways cube ain't the only one who got the classic mark
-
how come doggfather didn't get reviewed ??? anyways cube ain't the only one who got the classic mark
they didnt review it b/c after doggystyle got 4 suge got pissed b/c it deserved 5 so he stopped sendin them albums to review