West Coast Connection Forum
Lifestyle => Sports & Entertainment => Topic started by: OG Hack Wilson on April 19, 2010, 12:03:18 PM
-
which 1 of these 3 do you think is the best?
-
carmelo 8)
-
Carmelo or Dirk; i guess it depends on who else you got on your team.
-
2 me melo hands down.
-
ever or right now?
-
ever or right now?
right now
all 3 of these guys are at the top of their games.....well Dirk might have had better stat years but thats cuz hes got more talent on his roster now
-
damn right til right now...im not up on game on their numbers right now...but id say dirk...and in the end hell prolly be better than both of em
-
Carmelo for sure
-
Pretty damn easy to rank these 3.
1. Melo
2. Dirk
3. Amare
Not sure how that can really be debated.
-
Pretty damn easy to rank these 3.
1. Melo
2. Dirk
3. Amare
Not sure how that can really be debated.
fixed ;)
-
Dirk and Melo is debatable, I would give the edge to Melo.....
but Amare without Nash is just above average....Really, hes not taking anyone off the dribble, and doesnt have a great mid-range game the way Bosh does...Or KG, or TD....definitely not on the same level as those guys IMO
-
Dirk and Melo is debatable, I would give the edge to Melo.....
but Amare without Nash is just above average....Really, hes not taking anyone off the dribble, and doesnt have a great mid-range game the way Bosh does...Or KG, or TD....definitely not on the same level as those guys IMO
without a doubt. He's basically an alleyoop guy. He's not BAD obviously. But his skill level has never caught up with his athletisism. Its too bad too. Cus with the type of athlete he is...he COULDA been dominate.
-
wait you sayin amare without nash on the same team aint shit?
-
wait you sayin amare without nash on the same team aint shit?
not "aint shit". His game is just SO enhanced by having Nash. Those other players mentioned...KG, TD, etc...are...or have been the creators for their team. The offense goes THROUGH them. They set up guys. They create their own shots and control the game. Amare just benifits from Nash setting him up....and Nash controlling the game.
-
damn so it sounds like u agree with nash bein one of the top 50 players of all time?
-
damn so it sounds like u agree with nash bein one of the top 50 players of all time?
I dunno about top 50. But he's been pretty damn good throughout his career. I give him credit...and to be real it took me a while to do so. But the older he gets...and the more consistent he stays....he's pretty impressive.
-
aite cool...at least they put him at 50...lol
damn so it sounds like u agree with nash bein one of the top 50 players of all time?
I dunno about top 50. But he's been pretty damn good throughout his career. I give him credit...and to be real it took me a while to do so. But the older he gets...and the more consistent he stays....he's pretty impressive.
-
Steve Nash is sick....Dude is 8th ALL TIME in assists. Considering he didnt get much action early on in his career, thats pretty impressive. And Amare can thank Nash for assisting on THOUSANDS of his career points as well. Look at Marion, dude was never the same player after he left Phoenix. Amare will be the same. His numbers will go down unless get gets on a team with Chris Paul.
-
damn so it sounds like u agree with nash bein one of the top 50 players of all time?
I dunno about top 50. But he's been pretty damn good throughout his career. I give him credit...and to be real it took me a while to do so. But the older he gets...and the more consistent he stays....he's pretty impressive.
50?
i think he deserves more than that
-
damn so it sounds like u agree with nash bein one of the top 50 players of all time?
I dunno about top 50. But he's been pretty damn good throughout his career. I give him credit...and to be real it took me a while to do so. But the older he gets...and the more consistent he stays....he's pretty impressive.
50?
i think he deserves more than that
When they originally did the top 50 all time...players had to be left off that deserved it. Now...youre talking many years later...its even more difficult. I mean 50 EVER?! Everytime you add a new name...you have to bump out somebody else. Lets assume that top 50 means....10 best players at each position (5 positions on the floor). I know it doesnt work exactly like this...Im just saying. That would make Nash a top 10 ALL TIME point guard in order for him to be a top 50 ALL TIME player. Is he a top 10 All time PG? Maybe. But tough to say.
-
damn so it sounds like u agree with nash bein one of the top 50 players of all time?
I dunno about top 50. But he's been pretty damn good throughout his career. I give him credit...and to be real it took me a while to do so. But the older he gets...and the more consistent he stays....he's pretty impressive.
50?
i think he deserves more than that
When they originally did the top 50 all time...players had to be left off that deserved it. Now...youre talking many years later...its even more difficult. I mean 50 EVER?! Everytime you add a new name...you have to bump out somebody else. Lets assume that top 50 means....10 best players at each position (5 positions on the floor). I know it doesnt work exactly like this...Im just saying. That would make Nash a top 10 ALL TIME point guard in order for him to be a top 50 ALL TIME player. Is he a top 10 All time PG? Maybe. But tough to say.
I think he is a top 10 all time PG....He is 8th all time in assists right now, and will most likely finish his career as top 5 all time assist man. Plus, Im sure his free throw and three point percentages are among the best all time of PG on that list. Im not sure where he ranks in terms of point production from PGs tho...
-
well at least they put him at the end and a.i. up the list