West Coast Connection Forum

DUBCC - Tha Connection => Outbound Connection => Topic started by: Kill on August 25, 2005, 06:25:10 AM

Title: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Kill on August 25, 2005, 06:25:10 AM
P i n k          F l o y d

THE WALL
(1980)

(http://images-eu.amazon.com/images/P/B000006TRV.02.LZZZZZZZ.jpg) (http://www.megaupload.com/?d=235XAAPT)

Roger Waters was exhausted. Actually, he had gone mad. In 1979, while Pink Floyd were promoting their latest album "Animals", their leader snapped and spit a fan in the face at a gig in Montreal. He´d had enough, enough of the rock circus, enough of business and enough of crazy shows with hyped up flocks of people about to lose control. Back home, he gathered himself for what would turn out to be the band´s - or particularly his - most ambitious project ever. And hence their most pompous and expensive one, too.

Roger Waters decided to build up The Wall. Not only was there a wall erected between the band and their audience at every live show, but also did that wall serve a metaphorical purpose throughout the whole album. In his process of recovery, Waters, along with digesting the experiences of the last tour gone wrong, immersed himself in introspection. What this resulted in was the lyrical and musical depiction of a country and the problems it posed to people growing up from a troubled man´s very subjective point of view.

(http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B00002E285.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg)

"We don´t need no education/ we don´t need no thought control" - simple as they were, the polemics aimed at Great Britain´s educational system and practically the country´s entire society, have been omnipresent to this very day. Youths who weren´t even born when the album came out still sing along, the CD (and the famous live record) can be found it virtually every store. Pink Floyd created a giant rock epic that remains permanently seared into the brains of an entire generation of fans. The analogy they used - a wall being formed and people robotically becoming "just another brick" in it - might have been so obvious it seemed a wee trite, but it was almost uncannily efficient.

(http://www.gurmania.sk/trabalka/pf16cx.jpg)

Nevertheless, there are two sides to this bombastic project. "The Wall" was so bombastic it disappointed many long-time Pink Floyd fans. Critics weren´t entirely satisfied either: The album had a lot of snippet-like material and short songs, which to some people was not just complex, but confusing and chaotic. Moreover, Waters had almost completely taken control of the band and to some made the impression of having a megalomaniac solo project with the help of a bunch of friends going.

Hence, it might seem slightly ironic that what is probably the best song on the entire album was the one Waters only co-wrote; "Comfortably Numb" showcases the songwriting talent of guitarist David Guilmore and contains a performance on his instrument that came so close to perfection some found it scary. Along with this beautiful song came a few indubitably great ones by Waters himself though - "Hey You", "The Happiest Days Of Our Lives" or "The Thin Ice" are classics in their own right and impressive work in the context of the album. So while "The Wall" might come in as too bombastic to some, it stands as the most gigantic rock project ever to this day and is the most popular effort by one of the best and most innovative bands in rock history.

(http://utopia.ision.nl/users/vangilse/pictures/dortmund1.jpg)
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Kill on August 25, 2005, 06:26:13 AM
As for the hook-up....it´s 2 disc actually but I have it burnt on one. It´s more than 80 minutes, so if you want it seperated: "Hey You" would be the first track of disc 2
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: MidoriHaze on August 25, 2005, 08:20:52 AM
Yer nice

I rate Dark Side of the Moon over this album, but maybe your list might too. I thought this album was released in 1979 though?

I've never really thought about it a lot, but is there any significance to the 3pts of Brick in the Wall. Pt 1 seems to be like a lead up and pt 3 seems more reflective on pt 2, but i've never bothered to check up what it's all about.

My favourite track = Comfortably Numb
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Kill on August 25, 2005, 09:44:31 AM
Yer nice

I rate Dark Side of the Moon over this album, but maybe your list might too. I thought this album was released in 1979 though?

I've never really thought about it a lot, but is there any significance to the 3pts of Brick in the Wall. Pt 1 seems to be like a lead up and pt 3 seems more reflective on pt 2, but i've never bothered to check up what it's all about.

My favourite track = Comfortably Numb

yer, a reply lol. Some sources say 1979, some say 1980. You might be right...

Comfortably Numb is the best track on there, yeah...I even said it in the review, I fucking love that song

about the different parts of Another Brick in the Wall....it´s just the track the idea of the whole album is based on, I think that´s why they split it and made it three songs. They did something similar on "Wish You Were Here". The album is basically a tribute to Syd Barret, their original band leader who turned schitzophrenic and the most important song about him is the 9-part epic "Shine On You Crazy Diamond"...parts 1-5 are the first song on the album, parts 6-9 are the last one...if you ain´t heard the album btw, CHECK IT OUT.
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: HD on August 25, 2005, 10:46:35 AM
props i only got dark side of the moon but this link doesn't work?!
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Kill on August 25, 2005, 10:54:59 AM
props i only got dark side of the moon but this link doesn't work?!

 ???

for me it does
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: white Boy on August 25, 2005, 11:03:56 AM
top 25 for me, easily.
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Javier on August 25, 2005, 12:37:44 PM
Anybody know why Megaupload takes longer for me than yousendit?  I kept on reading everybody else is posts saying that megaupload is much easier and faster, but for me its not like that.   ???
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: HD on August 25, 2005, 12:43:45 PM
props i only got dark side of the moon but this link doesn't work?!

 ???

for me it does

nevermind! it works now! thanks!
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: BizzyR.I.P. on August 25, 2005, 12:57:00 PM
Hell yeah an Album I like. Comfortably Numb is the best track, the solo is just sick.
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Kill on August 26, 2005, 05:59:56 PM
top 25 for me, easily.

I know. Like I said, to me it´s way too bombastic and pompous...but I know I´m not the only one who thinks so and some top 50 lists don´t even have it. Overall it IS great, but if I were to make a personal favorites list, this would POSSIBLY pop up in the top 100. I´d put "The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn", "Dark Side Of The Moon", "Meddle", "Animals" and "Wish You Were Here" over this.


Anybody know why Megaupload takes longer for me than yousendit?  I kept on reading everybody else is posts saying that megaupload is much easier and faster, but for me its not like that.   ???

I dunno, yousendit fucks up when I try to use it (to upload)...megaupload works, and for downloading both are about the same speed for me


Hell yeah an Album I like. Comfortably Numb is the best track, the solo is just sick.

Sick is an understatement. That´s the album´s greatest moment and one of the best guitar solos ever in rock history IMO
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: BizzyR.I.P. on August 26, 2005, 08:29:19 PM
Quote
I know. Like I said, to me it´s way too bombastic and pompous...but I know I´m not the only one who thinks so and some top 50 lists don´t even have it. Overall it IS great, but if I were to make a personal favorites list, this would POSSIBLY pop up in the top 100. I´d put "The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn", "Dark Side Of The Moon", "Meddle", "Animals" and "Wish You Were Here" over this.

Animals and Wish You Were Here are both dope but only 5 tracks appeace is what kills it 4 those 2.
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Bramsterdam (see ya) on August 26, 2005, 08:41:45 PM
props buddy, I like this album alot!
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: eS El Duque on August 26, 2005, 08:42:38 PM
i remember watching the video for the album..or somthing like it at a friends house. 10 years old and watching hammers walking and shit trips the fuck out of a young mind lol
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Kill on August 27, 2005, 07:10:29 AM
i remember watching the video for the album..or somthing like it at a friends house. 10 years old and watching hammers walking and shit trips the fuck out of a young mind lol

lol yeah, you mean the video right? Cause there´s also a movie, and I´ve heard it´s actually pretty good
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Kill on August 27, 2005, 07:15:59 AM
Quote
I know. Like I said, to me it´s way too bombastic and pompous...but I know I´m not the only one who thinks so and some top 50 lists don´t even have it. Overall it IS great, but if I were to make a personal favorites list, this would POSSIBLY pop up in the top 100. I´d put "The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn", "Dark Side Of The Moon", "Meddle", "Animals" and "Wish You Were Here" over this.

Animals and Wish You Were Here are both dope but only 5 tracks appeace is what kills it 4 those 2.
well, it´s 5 tracks, but some long ass tracks. "WYWH" has no track under 5 minutes and is over 40 minutes long...and I think that´s a lot better than making 10 4-minute tracks would have been...no band ever made something like "Shine On You Crazy Diamond". "Meddle" is 6 tracks strong, but it´s got "Echoes" on it..."Pigs On The Wing" and the whole animal metaphor wasn´t a bad idea either...I like the animal metaphor much better than the wall one personally

i remember watching the video for the album..or somthing like it at a friends house. 10 years old and watching hammers walking and shit trips the fuck out of a young mind lol

lol yeah, you mean the video right? Cause there´s also a movie, and I´ve heard it´s actually pretty good
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: BizzyR.I.P. on August 27, 2005, 01:57:18 PM
Quote
well, it´s 5 tracks, but some long ass tracks. "WYWH" has no track under 5 minutes and is over 40 minutes long...and I think that´s a lot better than making 10 4-minute tracks would have been...no band ever made something like "Shine On You Crazy Diamond". "Meddle" is 6 tracks strong, but it´s got "Echoes" on it..."Pigs On The Wing" and the whole animal metaphor wasn´t a bad idea either...I like the animal metaphor much better than the wall one personally

Yeah I love both "Shine On You Crazy Diamond's" wonder how it would have sounded if they decided to keep it as one.
And yeah the metaphor for animals was a smart idea. And tha Wall has to much skit type tracks and I wish some great songs like "Good Bye Blue Sky" were at least 1 minute longer.
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Kill on August 27, 2005, 05:02:04 PM
Quote
well, it´s 5 tracks, but some long ass tracks. "WYWH" has no track under 5 minutes and is over 40 minutes long...and I think that´s a lot better than making 10 4-minute tracks would have been...no band ever made something like "Shine On You Crazy Diamond". "Meddle" is 6 tracks strong, but it´s got "Echoes" on it..."Pigs On The Wing" and the whole animal metaphor wasn´t a bad idea either...I like the animal metaphor much better than the wall one personally

Yeah I love both "Shine On You Crazy Diamond's" wonder how it would have sounded if they decided to keep it as one.
And yeah the metaphor for animals was a smart idea. And tha Wall has to much skit type tracks and I wish some great songs like "Good Bye Blue Sky" were at least 1 minute longer.


yeah...some of the stuff is too short, that´s true, and the whole gigantism of that album has its negative side...that´s why i didn´t put it THAT high, but of course I do have to recognize its significance in rock history...

and yeah, the Animals metaphor was dope..."Shine on" would have been dope as one too...on their greatest hits you´ll get pts. 1-7 and it´s dope as hell
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: eS El Duque on August 27, 2005, 11:30:08 PM
i remember watching the video for the album..or somthing like it at a friends house. 10 years old and watching hammers walking and shit trips the fuck out of a young mind lol

lol yeah, you mean the video right? Cause there´s also a movie, and I´ve heard it´s actually pretty good

the movie i believe lol
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: rafsta on August 28, 2005, 03:24:52 PM
pink floyd is the only band i really ever listened to and enjoyed thoroughly.

and i prefer dark-side of the moon over this too.
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: BizzyR.I.P. on August 28, 2005, 06:26:13 PM
pink floyd is the only band i really ever listened to and enjoyed thoroughly.

and i prefer dark-side of the moon over this too.

List ain't over. There is no way in hell he won't put it.
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Suffice on August 29, 2005, 12:06:59 AM
This is absolutely classic. Mother, Comfortably Numb, and Hey You are unfuckwitable masterpieces. Props, and i hope to see more Floyd as the list is revealed
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Denial! Is Actively Joinin The Revolution on August 29, 2005, 09:59:31 AM
Good Choice i know my mom has this album
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: white Boy on August 29, 2005, 04:36:31 PM
shine on you crazy diamond, off topic, but seriosly a 14 minute orgasm...

btw kill you quit on us???
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: Kill on August 30, 2005, 03:38:25 AM
shine on you crazy diamond, off topic, but seriosly a 14 minute orgasm...

btw kill you quit on us???
wtf are you saying lol? If you mean the list, don´t worry, no. 46 should be up today. I had a problem with the downloading, somehow the shit didn´t really work and this will be one of the albums I only have on vynil

and btw, "Shine On" is not a 14-minute orgasm. It´s a 26-minute orgasm ;D (there´s 9 parts, don´t know what you got, on the album it´s split into pts. I-V (about 13.5 min) and pts. VI-IX (about 12.5 min)....the greatest hits has pts. I-VII
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: white Boy on August 30, 2005, 06:12:20 AM
i ment the I-V is the dopest, the other part is sick too but not as sick as the 1st part.but ive never listened to it together...
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: coola on December 17, 2005, 05:05:49 PM
do you think comfortably numb is about taking heroin ?
Title: Re: Kill´s 50 greatest albums ever - #47
Post by: coola on December 17, 2005, 05:23:11 PM
oh btw... another brick in the wall is my fave track... comfortably numb is damn good though...