Vote: Should Eminem Stay Retired To Protect His Legacy?

[R1ZE]

Encore already tarnished his legacy.

Personally I'm not a fan of his music, but I know he has it in him to make a better album than anything he's already put out. He needs one last return to form before he can hang it up for good.

[KURUPTION-81]

With the right production and subject matter eminem could still make a great album.

[h2k4]

I don't see what the problem is.  Everybody is entitled to have a bad album.  Doesn't mean his legacy will forever be ruined.  I think this new album will probably be better due to  the fact of all of the stuff that happened around him.

[K.Dub]

he needs to un-retire to restore his legacy in my opinion.....currently it's very damaged....the new song is very encouraging tho....

yeah i was going to say, he needs to come back so people respect him more for what he was.

Yup, Eminem can if he wants to.

[7even]

He already ruined it with Encore and songs like Fack and so on. Haters will always remember him for that episode, so it really doesn't hurt his legacy if he puts more albums out.

[herpes]

Majority of hip hop heads look at his legacy as a cat that could of put out a true hip hop classic but catered too much to the MTV crowd.

[K.Dub]

He already ruined it with Encore and songs like Fack and so on. Haters will always remember him for that episode, so it really doesn't hurt his legacy if he puts more albums out.

I hate those types of songs.

['EclipZe]

If he comes with that encore bullshit repeat again tell him to fuck off. I voted Yes.

but if magically he finds his inner-idiot again and starts dissing everyone again and not giving a fuck PLEASE COME BACK!

[D-Nice]

His legacy will always remain. "The Slim Shady LP" is a classic.

I voted no because he fell off after "The Marshall Mathers LP" and it's gotten worse with each album.

Yeah that is a classic, and Encore is the polar opposite. He got to come back and make it right after putting that bullshit out

[tonyscarbones]

these rappers need to realize they cant' be #1 anymore becuz their space in time is gone

next generation is in

just make quality music and albums if ur a real artist and fiend to create music

if not, don't make nuthin

em and dre are not gonna sell like kanye or weezy these days

thats a fuckin faact

[Chief]

^i'm pretty sure encore sold more than any kanye or weezy album?

yeah he should have a crack, but i dont think he'll come with the goods.

[Rugged Monk]

Em dosn't fuck any lyricists I care about. I never listen to his shit anymore, sounds like ass nowadays. So much more refined hip-hop id rather listen to...


SSLP, MMLP that was his golden age. It is going to be incrediblly hard for him to come back and do something fresh, I don't see it happening, although I do see him coming back wit some laffy taffy, toilet humour bullshit...