Football fans get in here and give your opinion.

[Noname]

Yea thats a good idea, im sure NIK will sticky the thread.

[KURUPTION-81]

Great idea i can see a lot of conflict in this 

[Javier]

Yeah I'm down. 

[Noname]

I got a better for voting, to make it more accurate. We start at one position, at first GK. People give first their top 5, after that, the first 2 players are nominated. And everyone votes between these 2. It takes a little more time, but it makes it a lot more accurate. Otherwise you would get so many different players, tie's maybe a difference of 1 and 2 between players.

[Intriago33]

Another good idea is an XI of current players, with only one player per nationallity.

[Don Jacob]

dope idea, this definately will be added to the dubcc sports hall of fame

remember it's not just going to be basketball and football(s) the hall of fame will be continuously expanding

[Mac 10 †]

Personally I think you should do as they do for Basketball and have the GOAT for every position in the team.

[Noname]

Yea thats the plan. So we can make a GOAT team. But we start position for position.

And i think the best way to vote is like this:

I got a better idea for voting, to make it more accurate. We start at one position, at first GK. People give first their top 5, after that, the first 2 players are nominated. And everyone votes between these 2. It takes a little more time, but it makes it a lot more accurate. Otherwise you would get so many different players, tie's maybe a difference of 1 and 2 between players.

So the winner of GK goes on goal, and so on. So for example you get a team like this.



____________ Kuyt ____ Kalou

Leonardo ___ De Guzman____ Ono __ Castelen

Van Bronckhorts ___ Konterman_____ Fraser ___ Van Gobbel

______________ Dudek_____________

[swangin and bangin]

Ravens should have won this year

sorry but them is talkin about soccer
read b4 u post son

[Now_Im_Not_Banned]

If you do it, ya'll should do it the same as Jake did for basketball and football...

[Sweet & Tender Hooligan]

I havent really bein payin much attention to what Jacob has been doin, sum1 wanna clarify? BUt this sounds like a good idea...

[Now_Im_Not_Banned]

Look a page back or so. Check all the polls made by Jake...You just gotta make a qualification thread where people choose their 10 best by position, then create 1 vs. 1 polls based on the winnners and keep eliminating players by round until the finals (round 5), which decides the GOAT...

[Intriago33]

How you gon do a GOAT when people started following at different times?
I meant, we should put a time scale, say from 1990 or something..

[Mac 10 †]

Yeah I know, it's hard to judge someone you've never actually seen play.

Are we gonna put Pele in there just on the basis of his reputation?

[Intriago33]

Yeah I know, it's hard to judge someone you've never actually seen play.

Are we gonna put Pele in there just on the basis of his reputation?

Exactly..