It's May 23, 2024, 03:59:58 AM
Quote from: D~Nice on November 20, 2010, 02:51:57 PMQuote from: The King on November 20, 2010, 02:50:15 PMWhy people hating? What did you actually expect? This song is fresh, lots of variety, well thought out. Best rap single I've heard in years. BANGINNNNNi stilll like to know why this song is fresh.
Quote from: The King on November 20, 2010, 02:50:15 PMWhy people hating? What did you actually expect? This song is fresh, lots of variety, well thought out. Best rap single I've heard in years. BANGINNNNN
Why people hating? What did you actually expect? This song is fresh, lots of variety, well thought out. Best rap single I've heard in years. BANGINNNNN
Becuz it's a good song that Dr. Dre made in 2010 that's why (if ur going to be technical). It's not even really all of that serious on tha critiquing, the song iz whut it iz, something to crank up.
The only thing I think that's fresh about the track is the mixing - Dre keeps on advancing with making everything bigger and crisper and clearer,and I think if anything saves the track for me it's the way that the song just jumps out at you in the mixingBut everything else about it isn't fresh --He's been using piano melodies for ages now-The claps are roughly the same -An Akon chorus - that's the opposite of fresh, everyone has an Akon chorus, didn't Crooked I have an Akon chorus at one stage-Sort of autotune sounding on that beginning bit - that shit is everywhere-More upbeat, dance tempo - everything on the radio is at that tempo nowadays-Doing a Nate Dogg impersonation... it's dope, but it's hardly fresh sounding-Neither of the verses are really anything in particular, they're sort of just generic verses, so it's definitely not fresh lyrically-Talking about smoking weed, which has been done for the last 20 years
Quote from: UCC on November 20, 2010, 04:15:50 PMThe only thing I think that's fresh about the track is the mixing - Dre keeps on advancing with making everything bigger and crisper and clearer,and I think if anything saves the track for me it's the way that the song just jumps out at you in the mixingBut everything else about it isn't fresh --He's been using piano melodies for ages now-The claps are roughly the same -An Akon chorus - that's the opposite of fresh, everyone has an Akon chorus, didn't Crooked I have an Akon chorus at one stage-Sort of autotune sounding on that beginning bit - that shit is everywhere-More upbeat, dance tempo - everything on the radio is at that tempo nowadays-Doing a Nate Dogg impersonation... it's dope, but it's hardly fresh sounding-Neither of the verses are really anything in particular, they're sort of just generic verses, so it's definitely not fresh lyrically-Talking about smoking weed, which has been done for the last 20 yearstrue but everything u just mentioned as to why it isn't fresh is tha same reason why people love it. i mean i agree with u but u just took apart tha whole song, broke it down part 4 part, and said u didn't like it (pretty much). like it's a song son, not a movie or a piece of food. Whut u just did is whut people call being OVER CRITICAL/OVER REACTING. i mean tha way u just made it look is like you're trying to dunish it before it even jumps off (like u have a plan 2 sabotage it or somethin lol). i ain't carryin' u but c'mon son, all that tho, you're basically saying that u dont like music period (let alone this song).
Word, I mean a lot of people did like it right away, it's just that lot of long-time Dre fans had complaints with the song... I think people forget or don't know that
Quote from: UCC on November 20, 2010, 12:43:05 PMWord, I mean a lot of people did like it right away, it's just that lot of long-time Dre fans had complaints with the song... I think people forget or don't know thatWell, I was one of those guys, for a lot of the reasons you listed. To this day, I feel Big Egos is 10x the song that Still DRE is. DOC on the lyrics > Jay. More developed piano-based chord progression. More substance behind the song, too, at least on Dre's verse. Plus, Hittmann did his thing on that song, dissing Mr. Hush Puppy
Best rap single I've heard in years.
Quote from: The King on November 20, 2010, 02:50:15 PMBest rap single I've heard in years.I respect your opinion, but in my opinion, it's not even the best single I heard this past week, which was that new Quincy Jones & Snoop one.
Yea I find people are looking waaayy to deep into this song. It is a fun, head-nodding, club banger. Nothing else.
Quote from: Stan on November 20, 2010, 03:38:04 PMYea I find people are looking waaayy to deep into this song. It is a fun, head-nodding, club banger. Nothing else. I feel that's a cop out. It's like you're admitting the song isn't substantive, so you're telling people not to analyze it, because the song doesn't hold up to scrutiny. Think about that, and what you're admitting.If something is classic, not only is it viscerally pleasurable (for lack of a better term, haha), but it also stands up to intellectual analysis. Kush doesn't. I mean, when you listen to the instrumental, do you think to yourself, "This would be a perfect instrumental for a song about smoking!" NO, you don't. This song has a disconnect between what I call form and content. In other words, the content of the song (i.e. the substantive message of the song conveyed via the vocals) does not fit the form of the song (i.e. the musical aspects).If that's going too deep in analyzing this song, then ok. But by saying that, you're basically saying to me that this song can't hold up to scrutiny, which to me makes it IMPOSSIBLE to be a classic. Classic music/movies/art do hold up to intellectual analysis and scrutiny.Not that you're saying this is anywhere near classic. I'm just making a larger point.