So who thinks Detox will top My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy's production?

[Detox Iz Not Active]

With all the anticipation, hype, and acclaim around MBDTF one would have thought it was Detox that had finally dropped

[Darkwing Duck (The Reincarnation)]

weird to compare 2 diff producers like that.
nothing is "better", one of the two styles suits the listeners perosnal taste more than the other..

do u like to compare DJ Premier with Timabaland?

[Action!]

i don't have a problem comparing.

i think dre's will be better mixed when it drops.  not sure if i'll like it more

[I_ThePope_I]

First of all, Dre doesn't have ghost producers. He gives them all full credit. And second, I do believe Detox will have MUCH cleaner production and mixing.

[.:Hercy Buggz:.]

its like comparing Apples and Oranges

[Action!]

yeah, they're both fruit

on that note i'm pretty sure ye doesn't use ghost producers anymore and hasn't since late registration.  he used to

[Triple OG Rapsodie]

yeah, they're both fruit

on that note i'm pretty sure ye doesn't use ghost producers anymore and hasn't since late registration.  he used to

he uses coproducers

[Detox Iz Not Active]

nothing wrong with comparing the two, they are both hip hop producers, those who say otherwise are just coping pleas for Dre


I think MBDTF will have a greater impact and be better musically, Detox will bump harder in the car and have a cleaner mix

[Gamestarr]

MBDTF production aint nothin special so it will easily be topped..

[Detox Iz Not Active]

MBDTF production aint nothin special so it will easily be topped..

nothing special? then what do you consider special?

[Lucifuge]

whtas so special bout nwe kanye album? nothin stuck in my ear,like wooow.

[EnzoUK]

whtas so special bout nwe kanye album? nothin stuck in my ear,like wooow.

yup, nothing really stood out to me either, heard most of the tracks n didnt even bother to download the album. its what i expected from a modern mainstream album.

[Matty]

i think Detox will be better. Kanye's album is impressive but it isn't exactly my cup of tea

The Book of David could be better than both.

[UCC]

MBDTF production aint nothin special so it will easily be topped..

Exactly, the only people who rate Kanye are non-hip-hop fans, always have been, because they don't understand hip-hop production in the first place

All the rock critics are like, "wow, he sampled King Crimson," when to hip-hop producers who sample, that shit is too obvious,
but rock critics think that Kanye invented this stuff, but he's got weak snares and his beats aren't put together nice

He's ok, it's not like he's terrible, it's just he's mediocre on the beats and his rapping is poor

[Portugoal]

That Kanye album had some weak songs on there, but I can't imagine "Detox" will be better than "Late Registration" or "The College Dropout".