My official album ratings as of 2003 (of over 150 albums)

[Twentytwofifty]

 

[Entreri117]

Lemme ask you somethin man...

How in the hell can you give Slick Rick a 10, and Chronic a 9.5?

[Jome]

Redman - Malpractice...7.5
Jay-Z - Reasonable Doubt...N/R
Method Man - Tical 2000...5.5
Nas - Stillmatic...9.5
Xzibit - At The Speed Of Life...N/R
Xzibit - 40 Dayz & 40 Nightz...N/R
Scarface - Last of a Dying Breed...8.5
Scarface - The Fix...9
Outkast - Stankonia...8

 

I pretty much agree with most of the reviews, and some of them I dont care/know about, but the ones I put into the quote is gonna be discussed..  

* "Malpractice" 7.5 - Way too harsh I think - actually I been bumping this CD in the car for 3 dayz straight, and there's so much dopeness on there that anything below 8 is a shame.
There's some many dope & hard joints on there, that I feel this is at least a 8.5

* Why don't you rare RD by Jay-Z ??

* Methical 2000 - 5.5 Iz you krayzie??
This is some of the grimiest gangsta gansgta-ish released in a very long while..

* Stillmatic - 9.5 - I still can't see why people consider this near classic, with all the average tracks on it.. (and The Source's opinion never counts)
I think people rate this as high as this, so that it will be impossible to say Blueprint was better. 7.5 in my book.. and that's when I'm not being harsh.

* Why don't you rate Xzibits 2 first albums??

* For the last 2 weeks I been going back and forth on "The Last of a dying" & "The Fix" to decide which is the best.
And "Last of a dying" wins by exactly 1 mic.
"Last of a dying" - 8.5 mics
"The Fix" - 7.5 mics

* Stankonia - 8 mics..
I have to disagree here too. There is so much different styles & new sounds on here, that this is almost classic..
Some tracks drag it down.. 8.5 or 9

* It is impossible to get 10 ??
I mean, not even The Chronic, Doggystyle or 2001 ??

[_That_Cracka_J]

C2Knuckles...you should do some song by song ratings of some of those albums and post 'em in Album Review.

[Don Jacob]

i use a 5 point method of rating but yeah i think you did a good job rating those albums some i disagree with but it's all good it's in range


just wondering since you said the chronic was the 2nd best album ever what is your first?

[dpgc2002]

Makaveli is  a 10 IMO...So is Doggystyle and the Chronic...And Meth's second album is at least a 7.5...I agree with most of the other ratings...Good Job...

[The Watcher]

i use a 5 point method of rating but yeah i think you did a good job rating those albums some i disagree with but it's all good it's in range


just wondering since you said the chronic was the 2nd best album ever what is your first?

Slick Rick  - The Great Adventures Of Slick Rick...10

[Vigilante]

That was a dope ass review...

Alot of the ratings were too high....but its tight and Slick Rick's album is exremely tight, he is one of the best storytellers there are!

[Don Jacob]

i use a 5 point method of rating but yeah i think you did a good job rating those albums some i disagree with but it's all good it's in range


just wondering since you said the chronic was the 2nd best album ever what is your first?

Eric B. & Rakim - Paid In Full

tight, i'd probably put that album in my top 5 rap albums too

[min0rity]

paid the cost to be the boss-8
makaveli-10
AEOM-10
me against the world-10
ready 2 die-10
chronic-10
doggystyle-10
reasonable doubt-9.5
safe and sound-10
rhythmalism-9.5
diary-10
warren g regulate-10
40 days and 40 nights-8.5
at the speed of light-9.5
doggfather-9
dogg food-10
last meal-8.5
top dogg-8.5
raw-8
stillmatic-9
infamous-10
lost tapes-8
god son-8.5



btw MMLP and TES = 9?!?!? LMAO.....

[min0rity]

btw MMLP and TES = 9?!?!? LMAO.....

And this is funny because...

..it ain't nowhere near classic

[min0rity]

..it ain't nowhere near classic

I think it's close.  I'm fairly sure in time they will be considered classics.  It's a safer bet than calling Tha Doggfather classic.

doggfather is a superb album