Classic Or Not A Classic (Part One)

[Twentytwofifty]

Which (if any) of these albums do you think are classic?

[smartass]

tical.

[.:Hercy Buggz:.]

fuck they're all classics

[PLANT]

fuck they're all classics

Id agree for sure....These albums have all stood the test of time, and to me that is what makes a classic album....The all hey great replay value and are all classic albums IMO.  Just becuase It was Written wasnt as good as Illmatic people say it aint classic.....When really, Illmatic could get 6/5, and It Was Written could get 5/5 and still be classic.

[Hatesrats™]

If I had 2 choose only 2..
outta those

ImO
Nas "It was written"...CLASSIC
One of the most anticipated lp's in a minute.
A world of pressure was probably on Nas' shoulder's when he was recording this album, he was expected to follow up one of the better debut's ever (ILLmatic)...ImO
considering all the music he has done since then, this one get's the nod equal or possibly better than STILLmatic as his second best title.


Method man "Tical"...CLASSIC
Only thing I can compare this 2...to compare it to now.
would be the buzz 50 cent had before droppin' his first official lp. Meth had the entire industry swinging from his nut's during this period. and he was was doing the grimey ish, that wasn't considered mainstream. His joint with Mary J was classic. (even tho the popular version, does not appear on his lp) I still to this day bump this on..
There is no question in my eyes that this one is a shelf life of forever in my collection.

Dope thread..prop's
Hatesrats 2oooTre

[LyRiCaL_G]

^^^ tru dat, gotta agree with hatesrats again, been readin some dope real shit off u lately dawg, good readin......props

anyways, another one......i say black star was pretty klose.......jus in a real different way, if y'all can jus chill back and listen to a joint for what it is by yaself in the nite when its dark n shit........check it out, its fuckin sick

peace

[OpTiCaL]

fuck they're all classics

Yep...my favourites are tical...illmatic..black star...ironman...then that particular gangstarr album

[Twentytwofifty]

Yep...my favourites are tical...illmatic it was written...black star...ironman...then that particular gangstarr album

[Skindiana bon3z]

All of em....but i can't speak on the blackstar album cause i dont have that one...

[white Boy]

 

If I had 2 choose only 2..
outta those

ImO
Nas "It was written"...CLASSIC
One of the most anticipated lp's in a minute.
A world of pressure was probably on Nas' shoulder's when he was recording this album, he was expected to follow up one of the better debut's ever (ILLmatic)...ImO
considering all the music he has done since then, this one get's the nod equal or possibly better than STILLmatic as his second best title.


Method man "Tical"...CLASSIC
Only thing I can compare this 2...to compare it to now.
would be the buzz 50 cent had before droppin' his first official lp. Meth had the entire industry swinging from his nut's during this period. and he was was doing the grimey ish, that wasn't considered mainstream. His joint with Mary J was classic. (even tho the popular version, does not appear on his lp) I still to this day bump this on..
There is no question in my eyes that this one is a shelf life of forever in my collection.

def

[Vigilante]

Nas "It was written"..WAY OVERRATED, AZ'S PIECES OF MAN IS AS DOPE AS THIS OR EVEN BETTER

Method man "Tical"...his prime, his time is over....4.5/ 5



Ghostface - Ironman.....4/5 , def not

Gangstarr - Moment of Truth....4.25-4.5/5 ....dope, not classic
Blackstar - 4.25/5, Black on Both Sides is better

[Don Jacob]

i don't really think any of them are classic but if i had to pick one it'd be the Ticallion stallion

[Darksider]

I don`t like the word classic but all these cds are very tight.

[mauzip]

I don`t like the word classic but all these cds are very tight.

that's right.

[KING VerbalAssaulta]

only ironman is a classic in that list