Star Wars Episode III (rate it here!)

[Javier]

8.5

[BAY_BOY_408]

i give it a 10...A FUCKIN 10

[eS El Duque]

8

("everybody in the theatre please turn off their cellphones, pagers..and lightsabers. Enjoy the movie.")

[Javier]

i give it a 10...A FUCKIN 10

off topic...

harden would be another Ace in ur A's.  Btw, what part of Michoacan do you represent?

[Trauma-san]

First off, the entire series is essential.  You have got to see all of these movies before you die, they're some of the greatest shit ever filmed. 

Anyways, I'd say something like

Episode 1: The Phantom Menace - 7.5
Episode 2: The Clone Wars - 8.5
Episode 3: The Revenge Of The Sith - 9
Episode 4: Star Wars A New Beginning - 8
Episode 5: The Empire Strikes Back - 9
Episode 6: The Return Of the Jedi - 10

[-CaliKid-]

9

[Acgrundy]

Its hard to put a number rating on it.  definately 2 thumbs up.  by far the best out of the new series, not dissapointing at all.  I'd probably say 8.5.  Great movie, too bad lucas didn't make the first 2 this well.

[Sikotic™]

7.5

[MANBEARPIG.]

First off, the entire series is essential.  You have got to see all of these movies before you die, they're some of the greatest shit ever filmed. 

Anyways, I'd say something like

Episode 1: The Phantom Menace - 7.5
Episode 2: The Clone Wars - 8.5
Episode 3: The Revenge Of The Sith - 9
Episode 4: Star Wars A New Beginning - 8
Episode 5: The Empire Strikes Back - 9
Episode 6: The Return Of the Jedi - 10

In order to get the full depth of Revenge of The Sith and Attack of the Clones you NEED to watch the CN micro series Clone wars, it's as good as any of the movies and Lucas intended for people to see that before Revenge as was hinted in the prologue.  I'm still holding true to Empire Strikes Back as the greatest.

Episode 1: The Phantom Menace - 7
Episode 2: Attack Of The Clones - 8
Episode 2.5: The Clone Wars Micro Series
Episode 3: The Revenge Of The Sith - 9
Episode 4: A New Hope - 8.5
Episode 5: The Empire Strikes Back - 9.5
Episode 6: The Return Of the Jedi - 8

[LAZY]

ill give it an 8, it is the best of the new ones though, they shouldntv killed Jango Fett the way they did in Attack of the Clones and Han Solo is still the best character out of the whole series!

[Don Jacob]

8.75 it's a lil better than an 8.5 but not a 9 .

the story is PERFECT and lived up to everything it was suppose to be but the only thing holding it back was the acting it seemed like they reading q cards at times

[mauzip]

i already knew that dude would become darth vader

[Don Seer]

lol..

as far as ratings got i pretty much agree with Maximilian Chase
but what i've seen of clone wars looked wack..

i really didn't like the emperor either from the look or the acting or anything beyond the point of the fight with mace windu

anakins 'death' was dope.. but i felt they rushed the final bit where they tied up loose ends somewhat



i think they didnt emphasise the passing of time well in places.. some parts obviously take place much longer after others


i have some questions left over after this movie..

- anakin never tells obi-wan to give his lightsabre to luke.. in fact before their fight anakin doesnt even know obi-wan knows the kid is anakins

- how does anakin/vader learn the force acension secret that qui-gon-gin came back to tell yoda bout, and tells obi-wan to learn coz at the end of ROT-jedi he's ascended


also just another observation

- anakin/vader never find out that he never really killed padme.. although he must figure somethings up since the kids survive..

[Kal EL]

I give it an 8.

I have to agree with what Overseer is saying. If you know the series you actually end uphaving just as many questions as you did before you went in.

BTW
The Darth Sidious was the Shit!!!!

[Trauma-san]

O, the whole light saber thing is irrelevant.  It was obi won's decision to give luke his saber, Vader had nothing to do with it.

I don't know what you're talking about on the second one (honestly, I'm ignorant of what you're saying)

and the third one, By the time Vader faces Luke, he's had 18 or so years to be on the dark side, by that time, it's irrelevant as to who killed Padme.  He's moved on since then and became so dark that he probably doesn't even give a shit.  He may not have even known luke was his until they were face to face, or maybe he just felt it with the force, by then who killed Padme probably wouldn't even be a concern to him, he's already a sith lord, running shit.  Ultimately, too, though it may have been one of the reasons he eventually killed Darth Sidious.  By this time he would have decided he didn't want to kill his son, and that Sidious probably killed Padme, etc. and all of that eventually mounted up to him destroying Sidious.  So that part doesn't create a problem to me.