West Coast Connection Forum

DUBCC - Tha Connection => West Coast Connection => Topic started by: mfaraj on August 09, 2026, 01:49:09 AM

Title: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: mfaraj on August 09, 2026, 01:49:09 AM
This is based on level of skills/bars, creativity, album sales/popularity, longevity


1.lil Wayne- Its wayne and doesnt need explaining  🐐
2.Emenim- lyrical genuis and the only rapper to sell a million first week more than once.
3.2Pac -Took hip hop to the next level
4.Kendrick-crazy catalog
5.Lupe Fiasco- Top 3 lyrcitist, he decided to dumb his music becasue he went over too many heads


Below are "5 honorable mentions"

6.Nas
7.kanye
8.Andre 3000
9.50 cent
10.Drake

In the streets they say youre likely to end up dead or in jail, being in the hip hop game doesnt make you exempt. One of the greatest to fall victim to this saying is Tory lanez

Easily the most versatile hip hop artist to ever exist. He has 3 different identities and is the only rapper to drop a full rap album from prison. I will challenge anyone to find me a more complete overall artist (versitile), hes the best rap artist to ever exist up there with Kanye

Rip Juice wrld, he was the future and would have been the new lil wayne the way kobe was the new jordan. At a young age he already worked with eminem and lil wayne having 4 tracks surpass 500M, 1 being 1.2B views in his early career. He also dropped a duo album with Future at only the age of 19! (wrld on drugs), He once had five songs, in the Billboard Hot 100 top 10 at the same time. The only other person to do that was the Beatles in 1964,  Wether is having the number 1 album while alive, to biggest posthumous debuts of the modern (after death), he continues to be heavily listened to and supported, and would have earned the permanent goat title knowing he would accomplish so much more had he lived longer. Especially considering all his achievements came at just the age of 21, four years younger than 2pac when he passed away
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: Sccit on August 09, 2026, 02:00:21 AM
good thread

ill start by saying mac dre and x-raided dropped full albums from behind bars well before tory


based on your criteria i got it at

1.2pac
2.eminem
3.biggie
4.nas
5.snoop


that's if u include sales/popularity

my personal top 5 would be

1.2pac
2.mac dre
3.tech n9ne
4.brotha lynch
5.biggie
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: TraceOneInfinite on August 09, 2026, 04:07:24 AM
good thread

ill start by saying mac dre and x-raided dropped full albums from behind bars well before tory


based on your criteria i got it at

1.2pac
2.eminem
3.biggie
4.nas
5.snoop


that's if u include sales/popularity

my personal top 5 would be

1.2pac
2.mac dre
3.tech n9ne
4.brotha lynch
5.biggie

Based on your criteria—mine and Sccit are identical  8)

My Personal top 5 replaces Biggie with Xzibit (and how can a West Coast head like Sccit have Biggie over Xzibit in a top 5)

1.  2pac
2.  Eminem
3.  Nas
4.  Snoop
5.  Xzibit
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: HighEyeCue on August 09, 2026, 06:04:09 AM
my list is almost the same as Sccit's just the order is changed

Pac
Eminem
Nas
Snoop
Biggie

my personal top 5 though as in favorites would be a lot different

Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: hitsaw on August 09, 2026, 06:17:24 AM
Pac
Nas
Snoop
DMX
50
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: Sccit on August 09, 2026, 07:04:16 AM
Based on your criteria—mine and Sccit are identical  8)

My Personal top 5 replaces Biggie with Xzibit (and how can a West Coast head like Sccit have Biggie over Xzibit in a top 5)

1.  2pac
2.  Eminem
3.  Nas
4.  Snoop
5.  Xzibit


i love xzibit and its true he's always been one of my favorites .. but biggies flow and storytelling was just next level .. and the fact that he's the goat of an entire coast (tho u can argue nas), it gives him that edge from a legacy perspective.
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: O.E.800 on August 09, 2026, 09:56:36 AM
I'm gonna skip the criteria list. I don't care about record sales dude. Skill is skill. Money can't buy that. There could be a whole other thread about what that means and whether people even know what is anymore lol. None of these are in any particular order except for 2pac.

Personal Top 5

2pac
Rakim
King T
Big Daddy Kane
Ice Cube

*Honorable Mentions: Black Thought, Big L, Snoop Dogg, Busta Rhymes, Xzibit, NaS, Crooked I, LL Cool J, O.C., Biggie, Redman, Method Man, Saukrates, Bumpy Knuckles, Jadakiss, The Lady of Rage, Pete Rock, Schoolly D, Slick Rick, KRS One, Ice-T, Krumbsnatcha, Big Pun, Teflon, J. Dilla



Bonus: Personal Top 5 Groups

NWA
Gang Starr
Westside Connection
M.O.P.
EPMD

*Honorable Mentions: The Roots, A Tribe Called Quest, Mobb Deep, Tha Dogg Pound, D.I.T.C., Tha Alkaholiks, Tha Eastsidaz, Cypress Hill, Public Enemy, Above The Law, Onyx, Group Home, Naughty By Nature



Bonus: Personal Top 4 Producers *Couldn't think of a fifth that could compete with these guys

Dr. Dre
DJ Quik
DJ Premier
Pete Rock

*Honorable Mentions: Soopafly, DJ Crazy Toones, No ID, J.Dilla
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: Sccit on August 09, 2026, 10:39:03 AM
I'm gonna skip the criteria list. I don't care about record sales dude. Skill is skill. Money can't buy that. There could be a whole other thread about what that means and whether people even know what is anymore lol. None of these are in any particular order except for 2pac.

Personal Top 5

2pac
Rakim
King T
Big Daddy Kane
Ice Cube

*Honorable Mentions: Black Thought, Big L, Snoop Dogg, Busta Rhymes, Xzibit, NaS, Crooked I, LL Cool J, O.C., Biggie, Redman, Method Man, Saukrates, Bumpy Knuckles, Jadakiss, The Lady of Rage, Pete Rock, Schoolly D, Slick Rick, KRS One, Ice-T, Krumbsnatcha, Big Pun, Teflon



Bonus: Personal Top 5 Groups

NWA
Gang Starr
Westside Connection
M.O.P.
EPMD

*Honorable Mentions: The Roots, A Tribe Called Quest, Mobb Deep, Tha Dogg Pound, D.I.T.C., Tha Alkaholiks, Tha Eastsidaz, Cypress Hill, Public Enemy, Above The Law, Onyx



Bonus: Personal Top 5 Producers

Dr. Dre
DJ Quik
DJ Premier
Pete Rock

*Honorable Mentions: Soopafly, DJ Crazy Toones, No ID

very respectable lists
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: Duck Duck Doggy on August 09, 2026, 10:41:10 AM
Snoop
2pac
Eminem
Kurupt
Rakim
Biggie
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: O.E.800 on August 09, 2026, 01:00:06 PM
very respectable lists

Good lookin ✌️

Forgot to include J Dilla under Honorables for producers and rappers. Also forgot Group Home for group Honorables. I knew I was gonna forget people but I'll edit the list.
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: O.E.800 on August 09, 2026, 02:17:21 PM
Just for kicks and in no particular order:

Personal Top 5 Most Unique Rappers

CPO Boss Hogg
Suga Free
Busta Rhymes
E-40
Sticky Fingaz

*Honorable Mentions: André 3000, Short Khop, AMG, Biz Markie, DMX, Lil Fame, Brotha Lynch Hung




Personal Top 5 Gangsta Rappers:

Eazy-E
Snoop Dogg
Big Wy
Tray Deee
W.C.

*Honorable Mentions: Goldie Loc. Dogg (from Tha Relativez), Squeak Ru, Jayo Felony, Mack 10, Nuttz, CJ Mac, Tha Chill, G-Luv, Young Maylay




Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: mfaraj on August 09, 2026, 02:27:31 PM
Skill will always outweigh record sales but the sales on a large scale confirm that the artist is liked on a large scale

You dont have to like a rapper to have him in your top 5, this is almost no longer opinion based, you cant keep lil wayne out of that top 5, just as much as you can not keep 2pac out, At one point your track didnt get played if wayne wasnt featured on it, one of the biggest peaks in hip hop ever

Theres also a difference of rappers that are enjoyable to listen to and rappers who are talented. Easy to listen to makes up for lack of talent when the flow and sound is nice but there are plenty of great lyricsit yall will not list simply because you dont enjoy playing their music, but it doesnt mean they are not great

The best of the best can do both, make the average person want to listen while also appeleaing to the hip hip heads.  thats how you get on that list
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: HighEyeCue on August 09, 2026, 03:03:58 PM
Skill will always outweigh record sales but the sales on a large scale confirm that the artist is liked on a large scale

You dont have to like a rapper to have him in your top 5, this is almost no longer opinion based, you cant keep lil wayne out of that top 5, just as much as you can not keep 2pac out, At one point your track didnt get played if wayne wasnt featured on it, one of the biggest peaks in hip hop ever

Theres also a difference of rappers that are enjoyable to listen to and rappers who are talented. Easy to listen to makes up for lack of talent when the flow and sound is nice but there are plenty of great lyricsit yall will not list simply because you dont enjoy playing their music, but it doesnt mean they are not great

The best of the best can do both, make the average person want to listen while also appeleaing to the hip hip heads.  thats how you get on that list

I don't think Wayne is top 5 though, if you put him in there then you would definitely have to put Jayz above him

and I like Wayne better than Jay
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: Jay_J on August 09, 2026, 03:14:38 PM
Esoteric (unique rhyme and flow)
2pac (content, persona, delivery)
Eminem (wordplay, content, complex rhyme shemes)
Method Man (umique voice, delivery, cadance and flow)
Dr. Dre (voice, actimg, delivery, cadance)
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: Sccit on August 09, 2026, 04:12:38 PM
Skill will always outweigh record sales but the sales on a large scale confirm that the artist is liked on a large scale

You dont have to like a rapper to have him in your top 5, this is almost no longer opinion based, you cant keep lil wayne out of that top 5, just as much as you can not keep 2pac out, At one point your track didnt get played if wayne wasnt featured on it, one of the biggest peaks in hip hop ever

Theres also a difference of rappers that are enjoyable to listen to and rappers who are talented. Easy to listen to makes up for lack of talent when the flow and sound is nice but there are plenty of great lyricsit yall will not list simply because you dont enjoy playing their music, but it doesnt mean they are not great

The best of the best can do both, make the average person want to listen while also appeleaing to the hip hip heads.  thats how you get on that list


wayne had an excellent prime in terms of bein the face of hip hop commercially .. all while bein a skilled emcee

but you're overrating him like u do lebron

i can't knock u puttin him in the top 5 based on your criteria tho
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: HighEyeCue on August 10, 2026, 03:33:45 AM
Esoteric (unique rhyme and flow)
2pac (content, persona, delivery)
Eminem (wordplay, content, complex rhyme shemes)
Method Man (umique voice, delivery, cadance and flow)
Dr. Dre (voice, actimg, delivery, cadance)

is this a personal top 5?

if so really dope list 8)
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: Young Old Head on August 10, 2026, 05:46:15 AM
I love seeing some underrated/forgotten, yet skilled and unique rappers being mentioned in here!
But my OCD also kicks in - can we please move this thread to the right section?  ;D


In the streets they say youre likely to end up dead or in jail, being in the hip hop game doesnt make you exempt. One of the greatest to fall victim to this saying is Tory lanez

Easily the most versatile hip hop artist to ever exist. He has 3 different identities and is the only rapper to drop a full rap album from prison. I will challenge anyone to find me a more complete overall artist (versitile), hes the best rap artist to ever exist up there with Kanye

Rip Juice wrld, he was the future and would have been the new lil wayne the way kobe was the new jordan. At a young age he already worked with eminem and lil wayne having 4 tracks surpass 500M, 1 being 1.2B views in his early career. He also dropped a duo album with Future at only the age of 19! (wrld on drugs), He once had five songs, in the Billboard Hot 100 top 10 at the same time. The only other person to do that was the Beatles in 1964,  Wether is having the number 1 album while alive, to biggest posthumous debuts of the modern (after death), he continues to be heavily listened to and supported, and would have earned the permanent goat title knowing he would accomplish so much more had he lived longer. Especially considering all his achievements came at just the age of 21, four years younger than 2pac when he passed away

I suppose u a 2000's baby?

What's Tory Lanez 3rd "identity? He raps, he sings... Which makes him only fit 1/2 into the top 5 rapper category imo.
He ain't the first rapper to drop a full album from prison btw, there's been plenty of others done it before him (Drakeo The Ruler, X-Raided, C-Murder, Shyne)

I also think Juice WRLD doesn't fit the whole debate either: Yes he had some big hits and was an okay rapper, but I don't think his lyrics or impact was bigger than XXXtentacion's, Mac Miller's or even Lil Peep's for example. Those "sales" don't mean nearily as much anymore in this streaming era. All these achievements u mentioned don't make anyone a top 5 rapper anymore imo. Playboi Carti (31 singles in the top 100 Billboard simultaneously), Lil Uzi Vert (26 songs) and Travis Scott (25 songs) have reached similar heights in terms of charts and sales, I still wouldn't put them in my top 5 (although I could see why some ppl would put Travis Scott in there). XXX got billions of views as well as other newer artists like YoungBoy NBA, Roddy Ricch or trash artists like 6ix9ine or Lil Pump.


Based on level of skills/bars, creativity, album sales/popularity, longevity, my top 5 would be:
1. Eminem
2. Lil Wayne
3. 2Pac
4. Kendrick Lamar
5. Nas

The rest (top 10 / honorable mentions):
6. Jay-Z
7. Drake
8. Three 6 Mafia (Juicy J & DJ Paul)
9. Snoop Dogg
10. Tie between 50 Cent and 2 Chainz


My personal top 5:
1. Nas
2. Jay-Z
3. 2Pac
4. Biggie
5. Scarface

Honorable mentions: Black Thought, Kendrick Lamar, DMX, Joey Bada$$, Big Pun, Jeezy, Cormega, Eminem, Lil Wayne, Ab-Soul, Freddie Gibbs, Spice 1, Elzhi


Personal top 5 rap groups:
1. Mobb Deep
2. OutKast (really the whole Dungeon Family)
3. Wu-Tang Clan
4. DPG
5. The LOX

Honorable mentions: ATCQ, D.I.T.C., Three 6 Mafia, Cypress Hill, Tha Eastsidaz, Westside Connection, Gang Starr, Onyx, Clipse, BTNH, G-Unit, Dipset, Flatbush Zombies


And to add a new category; my personal top 5 producer-rappers:
1. DJ Quik
2. Dr. Dre
3. Kanye West
4. Pete Rock
5. Big K.R.I.T.

Honorable mentions: J Dilla, Erick Sermon, Warren G, J Cole, Black Milk, Tyler The Creator, Pimp C, Soopafly
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: Sccit on August 10, 2026, 07:41:23 AM
But my OCD also kicks in - can we please move this thread to the right section?  ;D

what's the right section u think?

as a rule of thumb, any general topic that includes west coast rappers goes in the main section
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: Young Old Head on August 10, 2026, 11:21:46 AM
what's the right section u think?

as a rule of thumb, any general topic that includes west coast rappers goes in the main section

Hm, okay. Does that go for let's say a soundtrack that features a song with West Coast rappers on it too then? Because yeah sure, there will be a west rapper or two mentioned in a thread about the top 5 rappers of all time, but it's really about rappers from everywhere, not specifically the west 🤷‍♂️ so I think that would make it a "Outbound Connection" discussion. Just my thoughts
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: Mr. T H E O on August 10, 2026, 01:01:08 PM
ON THIS CRITERIA..

all these have excellent skillz, bars,sales, creativity,popularity and longevity

The quality listed in parentheses is their strongest one.

1 - 2Pac (all, skillz, bars, sales, creativity, EXTREME popularity even 30 years after death, longevity)
2 - Ice Cube (skillz,bars and sales)
3 - Drake (popularity)
4 - Kanye West (creativity) tied with Will.I.Am
5 - Lil Wayne (longevity..since 15 years rapping)


My Personal Fav Rappers Ever

1   Tupac Shakur
2   Ice Cube
3   DJ Quik
4   Suga Free
5   Rappin 4-Tay


Honorable Mention

Snoop,Mack 10,Kurupt,WC,Kam,Treach (Naughty By Nature),LL Cool J,Big L,Erick Sermon, Will Smith and The Game
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: Mr. T H E O on August 10, 2026, 01:09:19 PM
ON THIS CRITERIA..

all these have excellent skillz, bars,sales, creativity,popularity and longevity

The quality listed in parentheses is their strongest one.

1 - 2Pac (all, skillz, bars, sales, creativity, EXTREME popularity even 30 years after death, longevity)
2 - Ice Cube (skillz,bars and sales)
3 - Drake (popularity)
4 - Kanye West (creativity) tied with Will.I.Am
5 - Lil Wayne (longevity..since 15 years rapping)


My Personal Fav Rappers Ever

1   Tupac Shakur
2   Ice Cube
3   DJ Quik
4   Suga Free
5   Rappin 4-Tay


Honorable Mention

Snoop,Mack 10,Kurupt,WC,Kam,Treach (Naughty By Nature),LL Cool J,Big L,Erick Sermon, Will Smith and The Game

My dream is a Kanye West and will.i.am collab album, making straight-up hip-hop, produced by both of them.
These guys are from another planet.

Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: Sccit on August 10, 2026, 01:27:12 PM
Hm, okay. Does that go for let's say a soundtrack that features a song with West Coast rappers on it too then? Because yeah sure, there will be a west rapper or two mentioned in a thread about the top 5 rappers of all time, but it's really about rappers from everywhere, not specifically the west 🤷‍♂️ so I think that would make it a "Outbound Connection" discussion. Just my thoughts


outbound is basically shit that has nothing to do with the west

if a soundtrack has a west coast hit ala above the rim with regulate then sure, u can def post it here

 
Title: Re: Who is the top 5 all time rappers based on this criteria......
Post by: TraceOneInfinite on August 13, 2026, 05:02:44 PM
I don't think Wayne is top 5 though, if you put him in there then you would definitely have to put Jayz above him

and I like Wayne better than Jay

I don't have a problem with Warren being in anyone's top 5 — except the fact he is more like a producer and didn't write a lot of his lyrics.

But there's a strong argument for him being top 5 on the strength of his first 4 solo albums.  Not many artists had:

G Funk Era - Undisputed Classic
Take a Look.. - Near Classic
Want it All - Near Classic
Return... -  Solid

But how come nobody got any love for Xzibit??  Really he couldn't crack anyone's top 5 but mine?

Speed of Life - near Classic
40 Dayz - near Classic
Restless - Classic
Man vs Machine - Solid

Napalm — one of the great comeback albums ever by an aging rapper