49ers/NFL fans..

[Fuck Your Existence]

is it safe to say if alex smith loses the strating job to O'Sullivan that he is offically a bust (ala Ryan leaf w/o the psychosis)?

ive had the feeling since day one that the pick was a complete loss but just wanted some more opinions.

[Man On The Moon]

I'm a Niner fan, and to me he was a bust the minute he was drafted.

[Fuck Your Existence]

I'm a Niner fan, and to me he was a bust the minute he was drafted.

Rik,you aint never lied...+1

[.:DaYg0sTyLz:.]

Granny Smith > Alex Smith



But look on the bright side. You got yourself a solid 3rd string QB in Alex

[Fuck Your Existence]

Granny Smith > Alex Smith



But look on the bright side. You got yourself a solid 3rd string QB in Alex

fuck that,Michael Robinson played qb in HS and could no doubt give him a run for the 3rd spot.

[.:DaYg0sTyLz:.]

Granny Smith > Alex Smith



But look on the bright side. You got yourself a solid 3rd string QB in Alex

fuck that,Michael Robinson played qb in HS and could no doubt give him a run for the 3rd spot.

Everybody down here used to talk about Alex Smith like "damn....remember Helix high. Him and Reggie Bush on the same team". Now that I think about it, maybe Alex was holding the team back lol

["THE" MoSav]

i was very happy about Saturday night!!! Alex looked fine as well, but it looks like Jt's job, with time he proved he can make plays

[Fuck Your Existence]

i was very happy about Saturday night!!! Alex looked fine as well, but it looks like Jt's job, with time he proved he can make plays

im hopin for a jeff garcia type situation with JT...best scenario i can hope for @ this point.

[the ghost]

Imma life long Niners fan, but I gotta say that Smith=/= full time NFL QB.  I just don't know anyway else to say it.  Might be fine as a backup/timeshare, but full time he is not.  I know its tough to rate him given the sorry state of the niners line, and offense these past few years, but I think a lot of us that watch him week in and out don't see a gamer.

[Fuck Your Existence]

Imma life long Niners fan, but I gotta say that Smith=/= full time NFL QB.  I just don't know anyway else to say it.  Might be fine as a backup/timeshare, but full time he is not.  I know its tough to rate him given the sorry state of the niners line, and offense these past few years, but I think a lot of us that watch him week in and out don't see a gamer.

word,i'll admit he has not been in the best situation (as far as the o-line,diffrent o.coordinator every damn year,last years shoulder injury) but we have been lookin for just a flash or glimmer of what it takes to get the job done,bottom line he hasnt came through.

[the ghost]

Yup...just does not seem like he plays with any fire.

["THE" MoSav]

Smiths 2nd year he threw 2800 yds and 16 td's, and then we were 2-0 before he got hurt, and he never really recovered and shouldn't have come back at all, so lets not call him bust cuz in 06 he showed ALOT of promise, i think he just needs one more situation, where the Oline gives him some protection, cuz he has weapons and should have a good run game, the offensive line also is looking stong thus far..

[OG Hack Wilson]

49ers went mad downhill from 10 years ago

[eS El Duque]

Smiths 2nd year he threw 2800 yds and 16 td's, and then we were 2-0 before he got hurt, and he never really recovered and shouldn't have come back at all, so lets not call him bust cuz in 06 he showed ALOT of promise, i think he just needs one more situation, where the Oline gives him some protection, cuz he has weapons and should have a good run game, the offensive line also is looking stong thus far..

that 2-0 was misleading...there was no real offense even with going 2-0. I remember the monday night game..was boring as fuck vs the cards...i think Alex Smith didn't even throw 130 yards that night and threw like 30 balls went 50%.. the second game same thing, only difference he threw a lot less.. but .dude didn't even throw a td or pass 130 yards AGIAN and still manage to win cuz of Gore's running game.


Dude for some reason lost something at the start of last season. The only reason i know this shit is cuz i made the mistake of drafting him as my back up QB...

["THE" MoSav]

Smiths 2nd year he threw 2800 yds and 16 td's, and then we were 2-0 before he got hurt, and he never really recovered and shouldn't have come back at all, so lets not call him bust cuz in 06 he showed ALOT of promise, i think he just needs one more situation, where the Oline gives him some protection, cuz he has weapons and should have a good run game, the offensive line also is looking stong thus far..

that 2-0 was misleading...there was no real offense even with going 2-0. I remember the monday night game..was boring as fuck vs the cards...i think Alex Smith didn't even throw 130 yards that night and threw like 30 balls went 50%.. the second game same thing, only difference he threw a lot less.. but .dude didn't even throw a td or pass 130 yards AGIAN and still manage to win cuz of Gore's running game.


Dude for some reason lost something at the start of last season. The only reason i know this shit is cuz i made the mistake of drafting him as my back up QB...

true, but that was week 1, the next week he went 11 for 17. and threw no ints both weeks, the started to show life vs pitt throwing for 200 yds, then he went dwn..im just sayin give him one more chance...You also gotta remember in those first three games he had no protection at all...

I still do think we would be best off with Hill, hes a gamer