It's August 27, 2025, 06:51:24 AM
Total Members Voted: 12
I like Young and really pushed for him against Brady but this Bret Favre we're talking about. Better thrower and more of a Warrior. I can count on Favre. With Young I'd be worried he'd get hurt.
Quote from: Shallow on February 08, 2007, 08:50:08 PMI like Young and really pushed for him against Brady but this Bret Favre we're talking about. Better thrower and more of a Warrior. I can count on Favre. With Young I'd be worried he'd get hurt.not always, what about that CRAP he threw up against the eagles? He won 1 superbowl! Hes not a god. "This is brett Favre were talking about" Thats funny.
Quote from: "THE" MoSav on February 08, 2007, 08:51:23 PMQuote from: Shallow on February 08, 2007, 08:50:08 PMI like Young and really pushed for him against Brady but this Bret Favre we're talking about. Better thrower and more of a Warrior. I can count on Favre. With Young I'd be worried he'd get hurt.not always, what about that CRAP he threw up against the eagles? He won 1 superbowl! Hes not a god. "This is brett Favre were talking about" Thats funny.I meant count on him to be playing all season. I didn't think we were picking top QB for one game scenarios, but who'd you want long term to build a team. I'll take BRet over Steve anyday of the week, even in just 1 game scenarios. Young is more likely to get hurt and that's the main difference maker for me.
Quote from: Shallow on February 08, 2007, 09:48:45 PMQuote from: "THE" MoSav on February 08, 2007, 08:51:23 PMQuote from: Shallow on February 08, 2007, 08:50:08 PMI like Young and really pushed for him against Brady but this Bret Favre we're talking about. Better thrower and more of a Warrior. I can count on Favre. With Young I'd be worried he'd get hurt.not always, what about that CRAP he threw up against the eagles? He won 1 superbowl! Hes not a god. "This is brett Favre were talking about" Thats funny.I meant count on him to be playing all season. I didn't think we were picking top QB for one game scenarios, but who'd you want long term to build a team. I'll take BRet over Steve anyday of the week, even in just 1 game scenarios. Young is more likely to get hurt and that's the main difference maker for me.injuries aside id take Steve Young
Quote from: "THE" MoSav on February 08, 2007, 11:05:48 PMQuote from: Shallow on February 08, 2007, 09:48:45 PMQuote from: "THE" MoSav on February 08, 2007, 08:51:23 PMQuote from: Shallow on February 08, 2007, 08:50:08 PMI like Young and really pushed for him against Brady but this Bret Favre we're talking about. Better thrower and more of a Warrior. I can count on Favre. With Young I'd be worried he'd get hurt.not always, what about that CRAP he threw up against the eagles? He won 1 superbowl! Hes not a god. "This is brett Favre were talking about" Thats funny.I meant count on him to be playing all season. I didn't think we were picking top QB for one game scenarios, but who'd you want long term to build a team. I'll take BRet over Steve anyday of the week, even in just 1 game scenarios. Young is more likely to get hurt and that's the main difference maker for me.injuries aside id take Steve YoungI guess that would mean you'd easily take Brady over Favre. Keep in mind that if Dallas didn't exist Favre could have had another 2 Superbowls. He was a great QB on a great team but he had two of hte toughest teams ever to go through in the playoffs and rarely got home advantage. I think the key factor in the difference between Green Bay going in Favre's early years and NE going was home advantage because of the weather conditions. For either Dallas or SF to walk into Green Bay in January would be as hard as it was for Indy to come into Foxboro.If BRet Farve got to play in Lambaeu the weather itself would have taken care of the Cowboys and the Niners in my opinion. And then it would have been simple math against Buffalo, SD and Pit. I know homefiekld isn't as big as it's made out to be but when that home is in minus degree weather it makes a big difference. Young only won one Superbowl as well. Bret did get to two. And I know the bottom line for you is wins.
young was goodBUT THIS IS BRETT FAVRE WE ARE TALKING ABOUT!
my throat hurts, its hard to swallow, and my body feels like i got a serious ass beating.
Favre was good, but this is Steve Young we're talking about.