Detox or NWA album: Which would you rather have?

[_That_Cracka_J]

It's not like either of these two albums will ever come out, but I'd defo want a new NWA album.  That would be the shit.

[QuietTruth]

NWA Album....Only if the NWA album will have the still standing originals

[.:Hercy Buggz:.]

Detox could be a Hiphop Masterpiece while NWA could be another west coast disapointment

[QuietTruth]

Detox could be a Hiphop Masterpiece while NWA could be another west coast disapointment

True. Or vise versa.

[S.La*]

Detox.

It will probably change the state of mainstream Hip-Hop once again.

[Eihtball]

I just can't see an N.W.A. album working properly.  N.W.A. was all about the chemistry and the combined impact of Cube, Eazy, Dre, Ren, and Yella all together, that's what made them so great (and once Cube left, shit definitely fell apart, at least lyrically).  Without those five together, it just ain't N.W.A. to me.  And the reunion tracks ("Chin Check" and "Hello") were excellent, but not outstanding.  N.W.A. would do harm to their legacy if they tried releasing another album.

At least with "Detox", Dre can focus on just pushing the boundaries with production and doing it with fresh voices on his new tracks...what made his other solo albums so great was just listening to him reinvent hip-hop and push the envelope.  He can do that on his own; with N.W.A., it seems almost impossible.  So I'd prefer "Detox."

Though I gotta admit, the proposed title for the new N.W.A. album, "Not These Niggaz Again", sounds pretty cool.

[BCG1]

 Dre is actually my favorite rapper/producer, but on some real shit I'd rather have the NWA album

because they're all getting older and no one knows how long they got on this earth so I wish they

would go for it. (NWA would never ever be a Westcoast disapointment, get that out of here)

[eazye]

I'd prefer Detox for the same reasons mentioned above.And if Detox features Cube & Ren (I don't really think Yella would fit there, but who knows) we would have a lil' bit of N.W.A. probably for the last time.

[Okka]

Detox fa sho, but i would always love to hear somethin like "Chin Check" and "Hello" from the new NWA...

[West Coast Veteran]

An album fully produced by Dr. Dre with Cube and Ren on the mic > an album fully produced by Dre with 50 Cent, Eminem, Busta Rhymes, G-Unit, D-12, Eve, etc.

[TheDeli]

Detox first for me, could have an NWA tune on the album and see how that gets received then follow it up with an NWA album

[Bomb-AŽ]

id like 2 or 3 tracks on detox with dre, ren, and cube...that way we're all happy



peace

[KURUPTION-81]

id like 2 or 3 tracks on detox with dre, ren, and cube...that way we're all happy

[Gangstauu]

detox

[Elevz]

To be really fucking honest... I believe both would turn out disappointing. Detox might only commercialise rap music further and N.W.A will bring NOTHING new to the table.