DJ Quik vs. Dr. Dre

[R-Tistic]

Who would u pick for each question....

1. Who produces better songs?

2. Who's the better overall musician?

3. Who's the better rapper?

4. Who would have more success as a producer if they left the rap game?


I would say...
1. Dre. Although Dre has a much better talent pool, his beats usually blend more with the artists than Quik's beats do. Most of Quik's beats outshine the rapper by far. Compare the number of classic songs Dre has done compared 2 Quik.

2. Quik ANY day of the week. As far as pure music is concerned, Quik shits on Dre. Not only does Quik play all of his own instruments, but his musical structure is much much better than Dre.

3. Quik by far...even if Dre wrote his own shit, his delivery and all wouldn't touch Quik..no question.

4. Quik again....many of y'all may think I'm trippin but I kno this. Dre has a much bigger NAME, but aside from that, Quik is much more talented. In R&B Dre's name would make him more succesful, but Quik would produce much better R&B songs because of his musical knowledge. Now outside of R&B, Quik would COMPLETELY run shit. Quik could do Old and new school funk, even jazz, that Dre would never have a shot at.

[Suga Foot]

1. Who produces better songs?

In my opinion Dr. Dre does.  There is no right or wrong answer to this question as it's people own opinions.


2. Who's the better overall musician?

I have no clue.  I've never sat down and watched either of them play instruments.  DJ Quik doesn't always play all the instruments either.  Both Dre and Quik use musicians.  Dre keeps a production team.  Quik uses his 'family' (G-One, El Debarge).

3. Who's the better rapper?

Lyric Wise: Quik.  He's always entertaining.  But Dre has a better mic presence.  He raps with authority and confidence.

4. Who would have more success as a producer if they left the rap game?

I think Dre would.  Just because he's so much more respected outside of the rap game.

[R-Tistic]

2. Who's the better overall musician?

I have no clue.  I've never sat down and watched either of them play instruments.  DJ Quik doesn't always play all the instruments either.  Both Dre and Quik use musicians.  Dre keeps a production team.  Quik uses his 'family' (G-One, El Debarge).

Thats true...but even at that....what would u say Dre's most "musical" songs are? Whatever your top three may be from him, compare those to "No Doubt" "Thinkin bout u" "You'z a gangsta" "If we ain't fuckin (2nd II None)" "On my way (Suga Free)" All of Quik's Grooves...and the list goes on...Quik is a musical genius...I have never seen Dre in a studio but I know that even when Quik isn't playin all the instruments, he writes all his music handwritten usin notes and all.

[_That_Cracka_J]

1. Who produces better songs?
No doubt, Dre.

2. Who's the better overall musician?
Quik I guess....with the examples you just gave.

3. Who's the better rapper?
I wanted to say Quik because he's more entertaining to listen to, but Dre DOES spit his lyrics with more authority.  I'm kinda split on this one.

4. Who would have more success as a producer if they left the rap game?
Defo Dre because of name recognition.  

[Hatesrats™]

DJ Quik..

there is no comparisson..
Dre can't and will never be able to fuck with Dj quik.
Tha Q would never put his name on a track that he never produced....unlike Dre's casper azz....lol

"U ain't fresh"

[T.J.]

1. Dre.
2. Quik.
3. Quik.
4. Dre.

[Dedicato]

1. Dre.
2. Quik.
3. Quik.
4. Dre.

thats my answer 2

[Bigg Baller Loc]

1. Dre.
2. Quik.
3. Quik.
4. Dre.

[Funkadelic]

DJ Quik in every point...

[STILLDRE IS THE GODFATHER]

1. Who produces better songs?

In my opinion Dr. Dre does.  There is no right or wrong answer to this question as it's people own opinions.


2. Who's the better overall musician?

I have no clue.  I've never sat down and watched either of them play instruments.  DJ Quik doesn't always play all the instruments either.  Both Dre and Quik use musicians.  Dre keeps a production team.  Quik uses his 'family' (G-One, El Debarge).

3. Who's the better rapper?

Lyric Wise: Quik.  He's always entertaining.  But Dre has a better mic presence.  He raps with authority and confidence.

4. Who would have more success as a producer if they left the rap game?

I think Dre would.  Just because he's so much more respected outside of the rap game.

you right on point i agree with^^^^^^^^

[SikksTrey]

1. Quik
2. Quik
3. Quik
4. Dre (just because he's the bigger name)

[Gangsta_T]

DJ Quik..

there is no comparisson..
Dre can't and will never be able to fuck with Dj quik.
Tha Q would never put his name on a track that he never produced....unlike Dre's casper azz....lol

"U ain't fresh"

word up...

dj quik is the answer for every question

T

[Shark]

Dre just can't win this one.

[jacktheripper]

Suga Foot who is the lady in your Avator.

[Twentytwofifty]

1. Who produces better songs?...Dre, and that goes for albums too.

2. Who's the better overall musician?...probably Quik, but that's just what I see from the credits.

3. Who's the better rapper?...difficult, probably Quik but Dre has had some nice highlights

4. Who would have more success as a producer if they left the rap game?...Dre easily, Quik can't even really make noise in the rap game outside the state of California

Overall, Dre easy, more impact & influence and has produced the most undisputed classic albums.