It's June 16, 2024, 07:25:58 AM
Well vh1 has a show called Ultimate Albums and it had one episode based entirely around the MMLP. Whether any of you care for the opinions of vh1 is irrelevent. The fact remains that a national cable channel has dubbed it a classic and it is considred by at least the 17 million people that bought it world wide a classic. I'm not talking about the underground rap scene that hails shit albums from Canibus as classics. I'm talking about publications like Rollingstone magazine. So what if they're white guys writing the reviews? Eminem's white, and I bet so are most of the people on this forum.
Personally I feel both of the previous two Eminem albums were better than Ready To Die, Me Agaist the World, Hell On Earth, 36 Chambers, and 2001.
All I was trying to imply is that I believe (because I haven't tried it) if you were to go to a music store and ask if they considered MMLP or Eminem Show classics, that the majority would say yes.
Quote from: smartass on September 06, 2004, 08:35:19 AMeminem will never make a classic album. sslp will always be his best.He'll never make a classic album to you, but to the general music public MMLP and Eminem Show are both considred classics. Just because you don't like something doesn't mean it's not a classic. I don't care much for Thriller, outside of a couple singles, but I would never deny that it's a classic.
eminem will never make a classic album. sslp will always be his best.
Whether Personally I feel both of the previous two Eminem albums were better than Ready To Die, Me Agaist the World, Hell On Earth, 36 Chambers, and 2001. Those albums are considred by many to be classics.^^these eminem groupies need to go.......man whether u dig the album more than those is one thing but to claim its better its both a groupie statement and bullshit........
Quote from: Shallow on September 06, 2004, 11:26:49 AMWhether Personally I feel both of the previous two Eminem albums were better than Ready To Die, Me Agaist the World, Hell On Earth, 36 Chambers, and 2001. Those albums are considred by many to be classics.^^these eminem groupies need to go.......man whether u dig the album more than those is one thing but to claim its better its both a groupie statement and bullshit........
Quote from: Shallow on September 06, 2004, 10:41:18 AMQuote from: smartass on September 06, 2004, 08:35:19 AMeminem will never make a classic album. sslp will always be his best.He'll never make a classic album to you, but to the general music public MMLP and Eminem Show are both considred classics. Just because you don't like something doesn't mean it's not a classic. I don't care much for Thriller, outside of a couple singles, but I would never deny that it's a classic.why you coppin pleas for em? when did i ever say that i didnt like those albums?...and who is this "general music public"? provide some sources, cause like jay said "we don't believe you, you need more people" a classic must have replay value...what eminem album do you still play? if you consider eminem albums personal classics, thats fine by me, but i honestly dont see how any of them could be considered classics. that word gets thrown around on here way too much. theres probably only about 20-30 real classic rap albums.
HIP HOP isn't Rock 'N' Roll. WTF. We're juss talking about RAP (MCing) in here, nothing about Graph, Djing or Breaking mentioned by any1. HIP HOP is a culture.
Why the fuck are u comparing Nas to Bob Dylan? U can't compare the 2 man. This is a rap forum, get yer Rock N Roll bs outta here man! 2 different genre's, 2 completely different artists.
PS. Michael Jackson has never been Rock 'N' Roll, if he was considered RNR back in the day (WTF), thas prolly bcoz the term POP wasn't invented.
SSLP, MMLP - they're classic in my opinion.
Im thinking SSLP should be at least be considered a classicBecuase his single was something NEW^^
man we aint talkiin about rock n roll clowns in here, we talkin about hiphop heads....not linkin park and shit.....i like emiinem and i like nas.........but why the fuck u gon comapre him to bob dylan.......cvh1 dont mean shit nor duz rock clowns, we talkin about hiphop heads and what albums is considered classic by hiphopheads......man aintn no manz gon give a fuck about whether some clwon who dont know shit about proper hiphop claim eminem made 3 classics.........within hiphop headquarters........eminem has yet to hit a classic.......its a known fact.......dre got it, snoop got it, nas got it....not eminem......aint nobody sayin he aint dope..........but he aint made a classic yet and thats straight.....pz